Alfred W. Booth & Bro. v. Glasser
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The appellant filed a mechanics’ lien claim in the office of the clerk of the county of Hudson and brought its suit to enforce it in the District Court of the city of Bayonne.
The defendant moved to dismiss the action for two reasons ■—first, “'that the return day does not appear on the summons s'erved;” second, “more than fifteen daj^s has intervened between the date of the summons and the return day.” The trial court granted the motion and entered a judgment dismissing the suit from which the plaintiff has appealed to this court. ¿The question to he determined is whether section 23 of “An act to secure to mechanics and others payment for their labor and materials in erecting any building (Revision of 1898),” as amended in 1912 (Pamph. L., p. 470), authorizes a summons without naming a return day in actions brought in a District Court for the enforcement of a debt for which a lien is given for labor or materials furnished in erecting a building. This statute enacts, among other things, that “when the suit is brought in a District Court the practice shall be as nearly as possible the same as now provided, or may be hereafter provided, by law, in District Courts in actions on contract.” The act further provides that all suits shall he commenced hv summons similar in form to that set out in the statute, which in express terms provides a foi'vn for use either in the Circuit or District Court, “as the case may he,” and differs from the form required in actions on contract in the District Court, in that no> return day is required, but defendant is to answer within twenty days after service of the summons with complaint annexed. The defendant argues that the amendment was not intended to change the District Court act, which provides that a summons “shall specify a certain time not less than five nor more than 'fifteen days from the date of such process.” This contention is clearly'unsound in law.
The judgment appealed from will be reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.