Smith v. Cruse
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Cook v. Seidenverg (Wash. 1950)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The plaintiff’s action was originally brought against Violet 'Cruse and Charles Weber, in tort, but by written stipulation between counsel of the respective litigants, the cause of action was amended to an action on contract, a discontinuance was entered against Charles Weber, and the name of Violet Cruse was amended to that of Elvira Cruse. The court, sitting without a jury, gave judgment for the sum of $400 in favor of the plaintiff and against the defendant, from which judgment the latter- has appealed to this court.
The state-of the ease which was settled by the judge shows that he based his findings upon testimony which raised disputed questions of fact which were peculiarly within his province to determine, and that there is testimony in support of his findings, and, therefore, as has been repeatedly declared by our decision, such findings are not reviewable. The state of the case shows that the plaintiff rented from the defendant a compartment in her garage, in Newark, New Jersey, for the storage of the plaintiff’s automobile, and gave him a key to the compartment, and that the defendant had
The appeal is wholly without merit.
Moreover, the appeal, according to the record before us, shows no legal basis for a review. It does not appear that there was any request on part of counsel for defendant for a finding, of law or fact, or law and fact, and exception taken thereto. Hence, there is no point presented which can be reviewed on appeal.
But even if it be assumed that the points presented properly challenged the findings of the judge on the law and the facts, nevertheless, we must accept the state of the case as settled by the judge to be controlling upon us as to the facts established by the testimony. We have considered these points, measured by the test just indicated. The appellant’s first point is, that there was no testimony upon which the sum of $400 could be found for plaintiff. The state of the case says that there was testimony which warranted the find
Lastly, it is urged as the seventh point that there was no express contract to furnish sufficient heat to keep the car from freezing. The judge, on the testimony, according to the state of the case, found to the contrary.
Judgment is affirmed, with costs.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.