Schmidt v. Kyle
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Singer v. Schapiro (N.J. 1945)
- Pan American Securities Corp. v. Fried, Krupp Aktiengesell-Schaft (Hudson County Circuit Court, N.J. 1938)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
At the instance of the plaintiff-appellant here, a writ of attachment was issued out of the Essex County Circuit against
Upon the return of the rule to show cause the trial judge heard the testimony of one William A. Koch as to the merits of the transaction between the attaching creditor and the defendants in attachment. It is true that the counsel of defendants made no objection and participated in the examination, nevertheless, it cannot be overlooked that the examination into, and trial of, the merits of the case was without precedent and without the jurisdictional power of the court.
As a result of the proceedings had before him the trial judge decided that the writ of attachment must be set aside. The only question properly before the court was the sufficiency of the affidavit upon which the validity of the writ rested.
In Anspach v. Spring Lake, 58 N. J. L. 136, Mr. Justice Dixon, speaking for the Supreme Court (at p. 138), says: “But in the more recent eases, the true rule seems to have been uniformly declared to be, that on a motion to quash the court would not consider the validity or justice of the plaintiff’s claim, and so try in a summary and collateral investigation the main issues between the parties.”
In Woods v. Southern Life and Trust Co,, 87 N. J. L. 202, Mr. Justice Swayze, speaking for the Court of Errors and Appeals (at p. 204), says: “Ordinarily,” as was said by the Supreme Court in Anspach v. Spring Lake, supra (at p. 138), “the validity of the claim should not be tried on a motion to discharge the defendant or his property from a suit.” To do so deprives the 'plaintiff of his right to trial by jury in case the claim is contested, and it would require a clear case of abuse of the process of attachment to justify the court in interfering in this summary way. The learned judge then points out that where it clearly appears “that the only question involved is a question of law, and the law has been settled adversely to the plaintiff, the court may quash the writ.”
Now, this does not appear to be so in the present case, for the learned judge in his oral decision makes it plain that
The order quashing the writ of attachment is set aside, with costs.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.