Gaudiosi v. Micone
Gaudiosi v. Micone
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff’s theory of the case as indicated in the state of demand, was that the defendant Leahy, as sergeant-at-arms of the East Orange District Court, had wrongfully levied on rents of a parcel of real estate owned by the plaintiff, and that this was done at the instance of defendant Mieone, the plaintiff in execution in the East Orange court. At the trial an amendment was suggested and allowed by the court.' We have been unable to find the amendment itself in the printed book, but appellant states in his brief that by it the action was changed to one for money had and received. We may say at this time that the claim of error in permitting this amendment is without merit, as the facts of the case were fully understood on both sides and no surprise was possible.
The court absolved Leahy, the sergeant-at-arms, and awarded judgment against Mieone, who appeals.
There are only three grounds of appeal. The second, relating to the allowance of an amendment, we have already disposed of. The first is that the court erred in giving judgment for the plaintiff; the third, that the court “erred in reviewing orders of the District Court of the city of East Orange, and in nullifying the orders of said court.” We see no merit in either of them. As to the third, the orders were res inter alios actae, to which plaintiff was not a party and by which he was in nowise bound. They were predicated on the assumed ownership of Carrera, and amounted to no more than the merely formal procedure required to make effective a levy on rights and credits, not the subject of manucaption like a tangible chattel. We repeat, that in all essentials this is the case of the real owner of a chattel holding the sheriff and an execution creditor of another for a wrongful levy; as, for example, in Harris v. Krause, 60 N.
These considerations dispose also of the first ground of appeal, which is general in character.
The judgment will be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.