Mogab v. Antrim Motor Co.
Mogab v. Antrim Motor Co.
Opinion of the Court
This is an appeal from a judgment of the Atlantic City District Court entered by the trial judge, sitting without a jury, in favor of the plaintiff against the Antrim Motor Company and the Atlantic Motor Finance Company, for damages for fraud and misrepresentation made in the sale of an automobile. The defendants appeal.
At the trial the facts as found by the judge, upon ample evidence, established the following matters:
The Antrim Motor Company, being the owner of the automobile in question, invited the plaintiff to the second floor of
The grounds urged for reversal are that the judge erred in refusing a nonsuit or directing a verdict for the defendants; that interest was included in the judgment; that the complaint fails to set up a cause of action against either company; that there was no evidence of fraud on the part of either company; that no joint judgment would lie against the defendants.
In our judgment there is no merit in any of these grounds of appeal. We think there was ample evidence of fraud on
As to the point that interest was included, it is sufficient to say that this does not appear in the record of the judgment as returned to us. And in view of this fact we are not disposed to consider what is the effect of the- stipulation of counsel as to the action of the clerk in entering the judgment.
Nor do we think there is aim merit in the final point that there was no concert of action between the parties defendant. It seems to us that a jury, and consequently the judge sitting as such, was entitled to find that the parties defendant were actuated by the common purpose to unload this inferior car on the plaintiff at a superior price, and as part and parcel of this scheme the one conceived the misrepresentation and made it, and the other adopted and ratified it.
The judgment is affirmed, with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- CYRIL J. MOGAB v. ANTRIM MOTOR COMPANY AND ATLANTIC MOTOR FINANCE COMPANY, BOTH CORPORATIONS OF THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY (JOINTLY, SEVERALLY AND IN THE ALTERNATIVE)
- Status
- Published