Schroeder v. Whiteside
Schroeder v. Whiteside
Opinion of the Court
Each of these cases is identical in character and were tried together. The defendants in the suits are one Whiteside, a
The trial of the two cases resulted in a verdict in favor of plaintiffs; the jury awarding each of them $2,000 as against Whiteside on the charge of false imprisonment and $10,500 against the two defendants jointly for wrongful expulsion from membership in the union.
Our examination of the proofs in these cases convinces us that the total award of $12,500 to each of the plaintiffs is grossly excessive, and that for this reason the verdict in each case should be set aside. Eeaching this conclusion, we have not considered it necessary to pass upon the other reasons submitted by counsel for the defendant in support of his contention that a new trial should be directed.
The rule to show cause will be made absolute.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.