Frederick A. Jones, Inc. v. London & Edinburgh Insurance
Frederick A. Jones, Inc. v. London & Edinburgh Insurance
Opinion of the Court
This was an action in the Hudson Circuit Court based on a Florida judgment obtained by Jones, Incorporated, against the London and Edinburgh Insurance Company for a fire loss in that state. A verdict was directed in favor of the plaintiff and from that judgment the insurance company appeals.
The single question presented on the appeal is whether the trial judge committed error in refusing to admit in evidence, when offered by the defendant, depositions which had been taken in Florida under a commission obtained by the plaintiff. The trial judge rejected the offer on the ground that the depositions being taken at the instance of the plaintiff could not be availed of by the defendant unless offered by the plaintiff. The respondent concedes this view to be erroneous under the case of Wallace v. Lieber, 69 N. J. L. 312, but contends that even though received in evidence they would not avail the defendant, and that the error was in consequence without injury to the defendant.
There was, therefore, no error which was harmful to the defendant in rejecting the offer of the depositions, and the judgment is affirmed, with costs.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.