Langer v. Morris Plan Corp.
Langer v. Morris Plan Corp.
Opinion of the Court
The defendant appeals from a judgment in favor of the plaintiff in the sum of $165. On November 25th, 1929, plaintiff gave defendant his note in the principal sum of $300, to which was added $30 for interest, making a total -of $330, and agreed to repay the same at the rate of $33 each .and every month thereafter. Having paid $165 on account -of said note, the plaintiff sought to recover the amount so paid under section 6 of chapter 49 (Pamph. L. 1914), alleging that the transaction violated section 5 of that act as ■amended. The District Court gave judgment in favor of the plaintiff relying upon Morris Plan Corporation of New Jersey v. Schwartz, 150 Atl. Rep. 390. The case of Consolidated Plan of New Jersey v. Shanholtz, 147 Id. 401; 7 N. J. Mis. R. 876; affirmed, 107 N. J. L. 517, also seems controlling.
Chapter 49, Pamph. L. 1914, was amended by chapter 251 Pamph. L. 1928, and section 8 of the amendatory act provides that its provisions shall not apply to any loan greater -than for the principal sum of $300.
It is sufficient perhaps to notice that the defendant company did that which it was not permitted to do under section 5 of the act, as amended (Pamph. L. 1928, ch. 251). That act provides, in part, as follows: “ISTo such licensee shall charge or receive of the borrower * * * a greater rate of interest than three per centum per month. Such interest shall not be payable in advance and shall be computed on unpaid balances.” Although the amount of interest exacted was loss than three per cent, the act provides that interest shall not be payable in advance and shall be computed on unpaid balances. The loan company could have complied with the statute had they desired so to do. Since the note given violates both the spirit and the law of the statute, the plaintiff was entitled to recover.
The judgment is affirmed, with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- MORRIS LANGER, PLAINTIFF-RESPONDENT v. MORRIS PLAN CORPORATION OF NEW JERSEY, A CORPORATION
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published