Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1974

Hackensack Trust Co., NA v. Alvarez

Hackensack Trust Co., NA v. Alvarez
Supreme Court of New Jersey · Decided December 18, 1974 · Per Curiam
330 A.2d 359; 66 N.J. 275; 16 U.C.C. Rep. Serv. (West) 532; 1974 N.J. LEXIS 157 (Atlantic Reporter, Second Series)

Hackensack Trust Co., NA v. Alvarez

Opinion

Per Curiam.

Certification was granted by this Court, 65 N. J. 576 (1974), to review appellants’ pro se contention of an injustice in the entry of judgment in favor of plaintiff-bank and against appellants for $2816.30 and interest. The judgment wasl bottomed on appellants’ refusal to deliver possession of a motor vehicle to plaintiff-bank upon demand made.

We conclude, as did the trial court and the Appellate Division, that the bank’s perfected security interest in an automobile, purchase of which it had financed, was superior to appellants’ claim of a lien based on subsequent repairs made to the car and that upon default in the finance payments, the bank was entitled to possession of the vehicle as against appellants who had insisted on payment of their repair bill as a condition to releasing the car to the bank. See, Ferrante v. Foley, 49 N. J. 432, 438 (1967).

The damages awarded the bank, representing the then market value of the car, less credits, are supported by credible evidence. It was undisputed that the condition of the vehicle while in appellants’ possession deteriorated to a point where it had only nominal value.

Affirmed.

For affirmance — Chief Justice Hughes, Justices Jacobs, Mountain, Sullivan and Clifford, and Judge Confoed — 6.

For reversal — None.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.