Wilmington Trust FSB v. A1 Concrete Cutting & Demolition, LLC
Wilmington Trust FSB v. A1 Concrete Cutting & Demolition, LLC
Opinion of the Court
By the Court,
In this opinion, we address an important policy question concerning the proper scope of the record before this court and the extent to which this court may determine facts, if at all, when it considers a certified question from a federal court. The present matter arises in a pending certification case from the United States Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of Florida. Appellant has moved to strike respondents’ appendix, contending that the included documents contain information beyond the facts certified to this court by the bankruptcy court. Respondents oppose the motion, arguing that the additional information is necessary for this court’s understanding of the certified legal questions. In resolving the motion to strike, we conclude that this court’s review is limited to the facts provided by the certifying court, and we must answer the questions of law posed to us based on those facts. While an appendix may be filed to assist this court in understanding the matter, it may not be used to controvert the facts as stated in the certification order. Thus, we grant the motion to strike.
BACKGROUND
Fontainebleau was planned as a hotel-casino on property along the Las Vegas Strip. In 2005, a syndicate of lenders, with Bank of America as the administrative agent, loaned the casino’s developers $150 million secured by a deed of trust. In 2007, Bank of America, as agent, negotiated construction financing totaling $1.85 billion, to be disbursed in three stages. Over 300 contractors and suppliers worked on the project. Bank of America included in the agreement with the general contractor, and required the general contractor to include in its agreements with subcontractors, a provision subordinating their liens to the Bank of America deed of trust. Construction proceeded for a time, but at some point, it appears that Bank of America refused to advance further funds. Work ceased, and Fontainebleau filed a Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition in Florida.
Appellant Wilmington Trust succeeded Bank of America as administrative agent for the lenders. Respondents are a multitude of contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers who have asserted statutory liens against the property. Eventually, the property was sold, with the liens to attach to the proceeds, and the Chapter 11 reorganization proceeding was converted to a Chapter 7 liquidation.
A dispute between appellant and the various contractors and suppliers over the priority of their respective liens on the property is
Following appellant’s filing of the opening brief and six-volume appendix, which included the adversary complaint, answer, and other pleadings, as well as pretrial motion practice, respondents objected to the appendix as incomplete. Respondents maintain that appellant failed to include other pertinent documentation in its appendix, and thus, when filing their answering brief, they included a four-volume appendix that contained the other documentation they contend should be before this court. Appellant filed a motion to strike all but one transcript in respondents’ appendix.
The source of the disagreement over the proper scope of the appendix is the parties’ dispute regarding whether Bank of America met the requirements for subordination or subrogation. The parties vigorously dispute how the 2007 transaction was structured and whether, as a result, the doctrine of equitable subrogation applies. When the bankruptcy court announced that it intended to certify legal questions concerning these doctrines to this court, respondents apparently challenged the court’s decision to certify at this stage of the litigation, arguing that the court should first determine the facts surrounding the 2007 financing before considering certification. The bankruptcy court declined to do so, noting that should this court hold that these doctrines could never apply in the mechanic’s lien context, then the adversary proceeding would be resolved, as the facts of the 2007 financing would not matter and appellant would fall behind respondents in priority.
The documents in respondents’ appendix fall into four main categories and appear to be included for the purpose of informing this court that the factual allegations in the complaint and the factual presumptions in the questions, as drafted by the bankruptcy court, are hotly contested. First, respondents included several of the loan documents that were referred to in the complaint but not attached to the complaint. Second, respondents included a few, but not all, of the documents related to some post-certification motion practice in the proceeding concerning the facts to be used by this court in answering the certified questions. Third, some documents filed in the main bankruptcy case were included, and fourth, documents
DISCUSSION
NRAP 5 permits federal courts to certify questions of Nevada law to this court when no controlling Nevada authority exists. The certifying court must include “[a] statement of all facts relevant to the questions certified” in its order certifying questions to this court. NRAP 5(c)(2). The rule does not provide for certification of factual questions. NRAP 5(a). Here, the text of the bankruptcy court’s order included background information, and the court attached appellant’s complaint, which sets forth detailed facts as alleged by appellant. Essentially, the bankruptcy court has asked this court to perform an analysis akin to that undertaken when evaluating a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. See NRCP 12(b)(5); FRCP 12(b)(6).
Respondents contend that the facts asserted in the complaint and the assumptions included in the certified questions are not true. They maintain that simply examining the loan documents and comparing them to the complaint reveals inconsistencies. Therefore, according to respondents, additional documentation is necessary so that this court has the “real” factual context in mind when making its decision. Appellant counters that this court’s role is not to find the facts — that task remains with the certifying court. Rather, appellant contends that this court is bound by the facts as presented by the certifying court.
As the answering court to a certified question, we must determine the proper scope of the record before us and the extent to which this court may determine any facts when answering a certified question. A vast majority of courts hold that the answering court is bound by the facts as provided in the certification order. See, e.g., Piselli v. 75th Street Medical, 808 A.2d 508, 516 (Md. 2002) (disregarding assertion that injury was discovered earlier than stated in the certification order); Preussag Intern. Steel v. March-Westin, 655 S.E.2d 494, 498 n.2 (W. Va. 2007) (refusing to consider new affidavit intended to downplay certain facts in certification order); In re Patel, 242 P.3d 1015, 1017 n.2 (Wyo. 2010) (stating that answering court relies on facts presented by certifying court). The answering court’s role is limited to answering the questions of law posed to it, and the certifying court retains the duty to determine the facts and to apply the law provided by the answering court to those facts. See Janson v. Christensen, 808 P.2d
We are persuaded by the majority approach and hold that this court is bound by the facts as stated in the certification order and its attachment and that this court cannot make findings of fact in responding to a certified question. We are further convinced that while providing an appendix in a certification matter is not unusual and allows this court a greater understanding of the pending action, this court may not use information in the appendix to contradict the certification order. Because respondents’ appendix has been filed solely to contradict the certification order and the complaint, we strike respondents’ appendix in its entirety.
Although appellant did not object to one transcript that was contained in respondents’ appendix, a hearing transcript, that hearing took place after the certification order was transmitted to this court, and it thus appears irrelevant to the certified questions. If the bankruptcy court believes that this court should refer to that transcript, it may amend its certification order accordingly and transmit the order and transcript to this court.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- In re: FONTAINEBLEAU LAS VEGAS HOLDINGS, LLC. WILMINGTON TRUST FSB, as Administrative Agent v. A1 CONCRETE CUTTING & DEMOLITION, LLC A COMPANY PORTABLE RESTROOMS, INC., dba A COMPANY, INC. A TRACK-OUT SOLUTION LLC ABATIX ENVIRONMENTAL CORP., dba ABATIX CORP. ABSOCOLD CORPORATION, dba ECON APPLIANCE ABSOLUTE METALS, LLC AHERN RENTALS, INC. AIR DESIGN TECHNOLOGIES, LLC AIR SYSTEMS, INC. AIRTEK PRODUCTS LLC AK CONSTRUCTORS, INC. ALABAMA METAL INDUSTRIES CORPORATION ALLEGHENY MILLWORK PBT, dba ALLEGHENY MILLWORK & LUMBER CO. ALLEN DRILLING INC. ALPINE STEEL LLC AMERICAN AIR BALANCE CO., INC. AMERICAN CRANE & HOIST ERECTORS, LLC AMERICAN METAL FABRICATORS LLC AMERICAN PACIFIC EXCAVATION INC. AMERICAN SAND & GRAVEL, LTD. ANIXTER INC., dba ANIXTER INTERNATIONAL INC. APEX CONCRETE CUTTING AND CORING, INC. ARCELORMITTAL INTERNATIONAL AMERICA, LLC ARCHITECTURAL MATERIALS, INC., dba AARON SMITH OF ARCHITECTURAL MATERIALS, INC. ARCON FLOORING, INC. ARIZONA TILE, LLC ATLAS CONSTRUCTION CLEANUP INC. ATLAS CONSTRUCTION SUPPLY, INC. AUSTIN GENERAL CONTRACTING, INC. AUSTIN HARDWOODS, INC. AZ-PUS, INC. AZTECH INSPECTION SERVICES, LLC BAKERSFIELD PIPE AND SUPPLY, INC. BERGMAN, WALLS, & ASSOCIATES, LTD.-ARCHITECTS BESAM U.S., INC., dba BESAM ENTRANCE SOLUTIONS BESAM WEST, INC., dba BESAM ENTRANCE SOLUTIONS BOETHING TREELAND FARMS, INC. BRADFORD PRODUCTS, LLC BROWN-STRAUSS STEEL SALES, INC. BURKE ENGINEERING CO. C.R. LAURENCE CO., INC. CADILLAC STONE WORKS, LLC CALIFORNIA FLEX CORPORATION CALIFORNIA WHOLESALE MATERIAL SUPPLY, LLC, dba CALPLY DOOR SYSTEMS LV INC. CARRARA MARBLE COMPANY OF AMERICA CASHMAN EQUIPMENT COMPANY CCCS INTERNATIONAL LLC CECO CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION, LLC CELLCRETE CORPORATION CEMEX CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS PACIFIC, LLC CENTURY STEEL, INC. CHEROKEE ERECTING COMPANY, LLC CITY ELECTRIC SUPPLY COMPANY CLARK COUNTY FENCE COMPANY, LLC CLQTS, LLC, fka COMPASS LOGISTICS CMC GROUP, LLC CODALE ELECTRIC SUPPLY, INC. COLLINGS INTERIORS, LLC COMMERCIAL SCAFFOLDING OF NEVADA, INC. COMMERCIAL ROOFERS, INC. COMMUNICATIONS SUPPLY CORPORATION CONCRETE CORING OF NEVADA, INC. CONSTRUCTION SEALANTS SUPPLY, INC. CONSUMERS PIPE AND SUPPLY CO. CONTI ELECTRIC, INC. CONTINENTAL GLASS & HARDWARE, INC. COPPER STATE BOLT & NUT COMPANY, INC. CORESLAB STRUCTURES (L.A.) INC. CRESCENT ELECTRIC SUPPLY COMPANY, INC. CUMMINS ROCKY MOUNTAIN, LLC CURTIS STEEL CO., INC. CWCI INSULATION OF NEVADA INC. D&D STEEL, INC. D'ALESSIO CONTRACTING, INC. DALTILE CORPORATION DANA KEPNER COMPANY, INC. DERR AND GRUENEWALD CONSTRUCTION CO. DESERT LUMBER LLC DESERT PLUMBING & HEATING CO., INC. DESIGN SPACE MODULAR BUILDINGS, INC. DIELCO CRANE SERVICE, INC. DIRECT PAVING & GRADING DIRECT PAVING & GRADING, LLC DIVERSIFIED CONCRETE CUTTING, INC. DIVERSIFIED CONSTRUCTION SUPPLY, LLC DOOR & HARDWARE MANAGEMENT, INC. DOOR-KO, INC. DSE CONSTRUCTION, INC. DUNN-EDWARDS CORPORATION EAGLE ENTERPRISES OF TN LLC EAST IOWA DECKS SUPPORT, INC. EBERHARD/SOUTHWEST ROOFING, INC. EGGERS INDUSTRIES, INC. EIDS STEEL COMPANY, LLC ELMCO/FORD, INC., dba ELMCO MECHANICAL LAS VEGAS EM&C TRUCKING, LLC EMBASSY GLASS EMBASSY STEEL ENERGY PRODUCTS OF NEVADA, INC. ENGINEERED EQ. & SYSTEMS CO. EUGENIO PAINTING COMPANY F. RODGERS CORPORATION FASTENERS INC. SOUTHWESTERN SUPPLY FERGUSON ENTERPRISES, INC. FF&E PURCHASING ASSOCIATES, LLC FISK ELECTRIC COMPANY FLIPPIN'S TRENCHING, LLP FOUNTAIN SUPPLY COMPANY FREHNER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC. GALLAGHER-KAISER CORPORATION GARRETT MATERIALS, LLC, dba GARRETT MATERIALS PRO-BUILD GENERAL SUPPLY & SERVICES, INC., dba GEXPRO GEO CELL SOLUTIONS, INC., fka GEO CELL SOLUTIONS, LLC GEORGE M. RAYMOND CO. GILLETTE CONSTRUCTION, LLC GIROUX GLASS, INC. GLENN RIEDER, INC. GLOBAL SERVICES OF NEVADA, INC. GRANI INSTALLATION INC. GRAY-BAR ELECTRIC COMPANY, INC. H&E EQUIPMENT SERVICES, INC. HALTON CO. HAMMOND CAULKING, INC. HAMPTON TEDDER ELECTRIC COMPANY HAMPTON TEDDER TECHNICAL SERVICES HARRINGTON INDUSTRIAL PLASTICS, LLC HARSCO CORPORATION, dba PATENT CONSTRUCTION SYSTEMS HD SUPPLY CONSTRUCTION SUPPLY, LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, dba HD SUPPLY INC. HD SUPPLY WATERWORKS, LP HD SUPPLY WATERWORKS, LP, dba HD SUPPLY WATERWORKS PC REGION HD SUPPLY WATERWORKS, LP, dba HD SUPPLY WHITE CAP HEATING AND COOLING SUPPLY, INC. HELOU & SONS, INC., dba HELOU CONSTRUCTION, INC. HENRI SPECIALTIES CO., INC., OF NEVADA HERSH-BERGER BROS. WELDING, INC. HERTZ EQUIPMENT RENTAL CORPORATION HILTI, INC. HOTZ, LLC, dba DRI-DESIGN IBA CONSULTANTS WEST, LLC IDEAL MECHANICAL, INC. ILLUMINATING CONCEPTS, LTD. INNCOM INTERNATIONAL, INC. INSTEEL, LLC INSULFOAM LLC INSULPRO PROJECTS, INC., dba GALE BUILDING PRODUCTS INTEGRATED MECHANICAL GROUP, LLC, dba IMG MECHANICAL GROUP INTERMOUNTAIN LOCK & SUPPLY CO., dba INTERMOUNTAIN LOCK & SECURITY ITAL STONE, INC. J&J ENTERPRISES SERVICES, INC. J.F. DUNCAN INDUSTRIES, INC., dba DURAY J.B.A. CONSULTING ENGINEERS, INC. JANIS SERVICES WEST, LLC JENSEN ENTERPRISES, INC., dba JENSEN PRECAST JOHN A. MARTIN & ASSOCIATES OF NEVADA, INC. JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC. JOHNSON CONTROLS, INC., dba JPRA ARCHITECTS, P.C. JS&S, INC. K&K CONSTRUCTION SUPPLY, INC. KCG, INC., dba REW MATERIALS KEENAN, HOPKINS, SUDER & STOWELL CONTRACTORS, INC. KELLY'S PIPE & SUPPLY CO., INC. KIMLEY-HORN AND ASSOCIATES, INC. KNORR SYSTEMS, INC. L&P INTERIORS, LLC L&W SUPPLY CORPORATION, dba CALPLY L.A. NEVADA, INC., dba G&G SYSTEMS LALLY STEEL, INC. LANGAN ENGINEERING & ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES, INC. LAS VEGAS AWNINGS, LLC LAS VEGAS PAVING CORPORATION LAS VEGAS ROOFING SUPPLY, LLC LAS VEGAS WINDUSTRIAL CO. LEWIS CRANE & HOIST, LLC LOCHSA, LLC, dba LOCHSA ENGINEERING LONE MOUNTAIN EXCAVATION & UTILITIES, LLC LUKZ TRUCKING, INC. LVI ENVIRONMENTAL OF NEVADA, INC. M&H BUILDING SPECIALTIES, INC. MAC ARTHUR CO. MARNELL MASONRY, INC. McKEON DOOR OF NEVADA, INC. MECHANICAL INSULATION SPECIALISTS MECHANICAL PRODUCTS NEVADA, INC. MECHANICAL SYSTEMS WEST, INC. MERLI CONCRETE PUMPING OF NEVADA, INC. METAL-WELD SPECIALTIES, INC. MIDWEST DRYWALL CO., INC. MIDWEST PRO PAINTING, INC. MIGHTY CRANE SERVICE, LLC MITCHELL CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC., dba WESTERN DIAMOND MODERNFOLD OF NEVADA, LLC MOJAVE ELECTRIC COMPANY, LLC, aka WEST EDNA ASSOCIATES, dba MOJAVE ELECTRIC, INC. MORRIS-SHEA BRIDGE COMPANY, INC. MUNDEE TRUCKING, INC. NEDCO SUPPLY NES RENTALS HOLDINGS, INC., dba NES RENTALS NEVADA CONSTRUCTION CLEAN-UP NEVADA READY MIX CORPORATION NORMAN S. WRIGHT MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT CORPORATION NOVA ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL OF NEVADA, INC., fka OWENS GEOTECHNICAL INC. OLDCASTLE GLASS, INC., dba OLDCASTLE GLASS WRIGHT CITY OLSON PRECAST COMPANY ORECO DUCT SYSTEMS, INC. OSSIS IRON WORKS P&S METALS PACIFIC COAST STEEL, INC. PACIFIC INSULATION COMPANY PACIFIC STAIR CO. PAHOR MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS, INC. PAPÉ MATERIAL HANDLING, INC., aka PAPÉ MATERIAL HOLDING, dba PAPÉ RENTS PAR ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS, INC. PARAMOUNT MANAGEMENT ENTERPRISES, LTD. PARAMOUNT SCAFFOLD, INC. PARTITION SPECIALTIES, INC. PAUL BEBBLE & ASSOCIATES, INC. PDM STEEL SERVICE CENTERS, INC. PENHALL COMPANY PERFORMANCE CONTRACTING, INC. POTTER ROEMER POWELL CABINET & FIXTURE CO. PREMIER STEEL, INC. PRIMARY STEEL, INC. PRIME CONTRACTING, INC., dba PRIME GRADING & PAVING PRIME FABRICATION & SUPPLY QED, INC. QTS LOGISTICS, INC., dba QUALITY TRANSPORTATION SERVICES OF NEVADA, INC. QUALITY CABINET AND FIXTURE COMPANY QUALITY TRANSPORTATION SERVICES OF NEVADA, INC. QUICK CRETE PRODUCTS CORP. RAM CONSTRUCTION SERVICES OF MICHIGAN, INC. RAMON FERNANDEZ, as Administrator of the ESTATE OF ANA FERNANDEZ RAUL ESCOBEDO RC WHITE CONSULTING, INC. READY MIX, INC., dba READY MIX CONCRETE RED MOUNTAIN MACHINERY COMPANY RELIABLE STEEL, INC. REPUBLIC CRANE, LLC RJF INTERNATIONAL CORP. ROADSAFE TRAFFIC SYSTEMS, INC., fka NES TRAFFIC SAFETY LP ROCKWAY PRECAST, INC. RONCELLI, INC. RSC EQUIPMENT RENTAL, INC. SAFE ELECTRONICS, INC. SAFEWORKS LLC SC STEEL, INC. SIERRA GLASS & MIRROR, INC. SILVER STATE MARBLE, LLC SILVERADO ASSOCIATES, LLC SMALLEY & COMPANY SMITH PIPE & STEEL COMPANY (WHICH WILL DO BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA AS CAZ STEEL COMPANY) SMK, INC. SOUTHERN NEVADA PAVING, INC. SOUTHWEST IRON WORKS, LLC SQUIRES LUMBER COMPANY STARLITE CONSTRUCTION, INC., dba SHAWMUT DESIGN & CONSTRUCTION STEEL ENGINEERS, INC. STEEL STRUCTURES, INC. STEELMAN PARTNERS, LLP STERLING CORPORATE CUSTOM ELEVATOR INTERIORS STETSON ELECTRIC, INC. STINGER WELDING, INC. STONE CONNECTION, LLC, dba SAMFET STRIPING SOLUTIONS, INC. SUMMIT EXCAVATION, INC. SUMMIT SAND & GRAVEL, INC. SUNBELT RENTALS, INC. SUNSTATE EQUIPMENT CO., LLC SUPERIOR TILE & MARBLE, INC. SYRACUSE CASTINGS WEST CORP. T. NICKOLAS CO. TECHNICOAT MANAGEMENT, INC. THE GLIDDEN COMPANY, dba ICI PAINTS THE PENTA BUILDING GROUP, LLC THE SHERWIN-WILLIAMS COMPANY THE SOUTHWEST CIRCLE GROUP, INC. THE WINROC CORPORATION (NEVADA) THYSSEN ELEVATOR CORPORATION THYSSENKRUPP SAFWAY, INC., dba SAFWAY SERVICES INC. (LV) THYSSENKRUPP SAFWAY, INC. TMCX NEVADA, LLC TOMARCO CONTRACTOR SPECIALTIES, INC. TOTTEN TUBES, INC. TRACTEL, INC. TRACY & RYDER LANDSCAPE, INC. TRENCH PLATE RENTAL CO. TRI-POWER GROUP, INC. ULMA FORM-WORKS, INC. UNION ERECTORS, LLC UNITED RENTALS GULF, LLC UNITED RENTALS NORTHWEST, INC. UNIVERSAL PIPING, INC. VALLEYCREST LANDSCAPE DEVELOPMENT, INC. VENTURA MARBLE, LLC VFC, INC. W&W STEEL, LLC OF NEVADA W.R. GRACE & CO.-CONN., dba GRACE CONSTRUCTION PRODUCTS WACO INTERNATIONAL (WEST), INC., dba WACO SCAFFOLDING & EQUIPMENT WALNUT INVESTMENT CO., LLC, dba ACOUSTICAL MATERIAL SERVICES WARD & HOWES ASSOCIATES, LTD. WASHOUT SYSTEMS, LLC WATER FX, LLC WELLS CARGO, INC. WHITE CAP CONSTRUCTION SUPPLY, INC. WILLIAMS FURNACE CO. WINTER COMPOSITES, LLC YOUNG ELECTRIC SIGN COMPANY YWS ARCHITECTS, LLC ZETIAN SYSTEMS, INC. Z-GLASS, INC., dba Z WALL INC. Z-GLASS, INC. AND JMB CAPITAL PARTNERS MASTER FUND LLP, as Assignee of All Claims Held by Assignor Lien ADERHOLDT SPECIALTY COMPANY, INC. AMI HOSPITALITY, LLC, aka ARCHITECTURAL MATERIALS INCORPORATED BOMBARD ELECTRIC, LLC BOMBARD MECHANICAL, LLC COLASANTI SPECIALTY SERVICES, INC. DESERT FIRE PROTECTION PEREGRINE INSTALLATION, CO. and WARNER ENTERPRISES, INC., dba SUN VALLEY ELECTRIC SUPPLY CO.
- Cited By
- 13 cases
- Status
- Published