Nevada Supreme Court, 2017

Lall (James) v. Warden

Lall (James) v. Warden
Nevada Supreme Court · Decided October 30, 2017

Lall (James) v. Warden

Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA

JAMES LALL, No. 71245 Appellant, vs. FILED ISIDRO BACA, WARDEN, Respondent. OCT 3 0 2017 ELIZABETH A. BROWN CLERK OF SUPREME COURT DEPUTY CLERK ORDER VACATING AND REMANDING This is a pro se appeal from a district court order dismissing a postconviction petition for a writ of habeas corpus. First Judicial District Court, Carson City; James E. Wilson, Judge.

Appellant James Lall argues that the credits he has earned pursuant to NRS 209.4465 must be applied to his parole eligibility as provided in NRS 209.4465(7)(b) (1997). In rejecting Lall's claim, the district court did not have the benefit of our recent decision in Williams v. State, Nev., Adv. Op. 75, P.3d (2017). 1 There, we held that credits apply to parole eligibility as provided in NRS 209.4465(7)(b) (1997) where the offender was sentenced pursuant to a statute that requires a minimum term of not less than a set number of years but does not expressly mention parole eligibility. Lall is serving a sentence pursuant to such a statute for mayhem with the use of a deadly weapon committed on or between July 17,

'Having considered Lall's pro se brief and given our decision in Williams, we conclude that a response is not necessary. NRAP 46A(c). This appeal therefore has been submitted for decision based on the pro se brief and the record. See NRAP 34(0(3).

SUPREME COURT OF NEVADA

(0) 1947A - 370% 1997, and June 30, 2007. 2 See NRS 200.280 (setting forth sentencing range for mayhem). Consistent with Williams, the credits that La11 has earned pursuant to NRS 209.4465 should be applied to his parole eligibility on the sentence he is serving. The district court erred in ruling to the contrary. 3 We therefore ORDER the judgment of the district court VACATED AND REMAND this matter for the district court to reconsider its decision in light of Williams.

J.

Tatrcal.sty

- cittjtaiejatrear asbeit..0 Stiglich J.

Parraguirre cc: Hon. James E. Wilson, District Judge James Lall Attorney General/Carson City Carson City Clerk Lall is serving sentences for other offenses concurrently with the sentence for the mayhem conviction. The sentencing statutes for those offenses, NRS 200.481(2)(e) (battery with use of a deadly weapon); NRS 202.285(1) (discharging a firearm at or into a structure, vehicle, aircraft or watercraft), do not specify a minimum term that Lall must serve before he is eligible for parole. See Williams, 133 Nev., Adv. Op. 75 at 5-10.

3 If Lall has already expired the sentence or appeared before the parole board on the sentence, then the court cannot grant any relief. Williams, 133 Nev., Adv. Op. 75 at 10 n.7. As such, the court cannot grant any relief as to Lall's sentences for home invasion and attempted murder with the use of a deadly weapon because he already discharged or was paroled on those sentences. It is unclear from the record whether Lall has appeared before the parole board on his current sentence. The district court may consider any evidence in that respect on remand.

SUPREME COURT OF NEVADA

10) 1947A e 2

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.