Nevada Supreme Court, 2022

Aerogrow Int'L, Inc. v. Dist. Ct. (Overbrook Capital Llc)

Aerogrow Int'L, Inc. v. Dist. Ct. (Overbrook Capital Llc)
Nevada Supreme Court · Decided June 30, 2022 · No. 83835
Aerogrow Int'L, Inc. v. Dist. Ct. (Overbrook Capital Llc)

Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA

AEROGROW INTERNATIONAL, INC.; No. 83835

CHRIS HAGEDORN; CORY MILLER;

PATRICIA M. ZIEGLER; H.

MACGREGOR CLARKE; DAVID B.

KENT; SMG GROWING MEDIA, INC.; rm,

AGI ACQUISITION SUB, INC.; THE i F fe i}

SCOTTS MIRACLE-GRO COMPANY; :

JAMES HAGEDORN; AND PETER JUN 30 2022

SUPRON, | ELIZABETH A. BROWN

Petitioners CLERK OF SUPREME COURT , BY -Yo.

VS. DEPUTY CLERK

THE EIGHTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT

COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA,

IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF

CLARK; AND THE HONORABLE

MARK R. DENTON, DISTRICT JUDGE,

Respondents, and

OVERBROOK CAPITAL LLC; NICOYA

CAPITAL, LLC; BRADLEY LOUIS

RADOFF; FRED M. ADAMCYZK;

THOMAS C. ALBANESE; WILLIAM A.

ALMOND, III; MICHAEL 8. BARISH;

GEORGE C. BETKE, JR. 2019 TRUST;

DIANA BOYD; ANNE CAROL DECKER;

THOMAS H. DECKER; THE DEUTSCH

FAMILY TRUST; JOHN C. FISCHER;

ALFREDO GOMEZ; ALFREDO GOMEZ

FMT CO CUST [IRA ROLLOVER;

LAWRENCE GREENBERG; PATRICIA

GREENBERG; KAREN HARDING; H.L.

SEVERANCE, INC. PROFTT SHARING

PLAN & TRUST; H.L. SEVERANCE, |

INC. PENSION PLAN & TRUST; |

DANIEL G. HOFSTEIN; KEVIN |

JOHNSON; CANDACE KAYE; LAURA |

J. KOBY; CAROLE L. MCLAUGHLIN: |

BRIAN PEIERLS; JOSEPH EK. PETER;

Supreme Gourt

OF

NeEvapA (0) 19470 RR ' - -2 Ob7e

ALEXANDER PERELBERG; AMY

PERELBERG; DANA PE ARELBERG:

GARY PERELBERG; LINDA

PERELBERG; THE REALLY COOL

GROUP; RICHARD ALAN RUDY

REVOCABLE LIVING TRUST; JAMES

D. RICKMAN, JR.; JAMES D.

RICKMAN, JR. IRREVOCABLE TRUST;

PATRICIA D. RICKMAN

IRREVOCABLE TRUST; ANDREW

REESE RICKMAN TRUST; SCOTT

JOSEPH RICKMAN IRREVOCABLE

TRUST; MARLON DEAN

ALESSANDRA TRUST; BRYAN

ROBSON; WAYNE SICZ IRA; WAYNE

SICZ ROTH IRA; THE CAROL W.

SMITH REVOCABLE TRUST; THOMAS

K. SMITH; SURAJ VASANTH; CATHAY

C. WANG; LISA DAWN WANG; DARCY

J. WEISSENBORN; THE MARGARET 5S.

WEISSENBORN REVOCABLE TRUST;

THE STANTON F. WEISSENBORN

IRA; THE STANTON F.

At WEISSENBORN REVOCABLE TRUST;

THE STANTON F. WEISSENBORN

IRREVOCABLE TRUST; THE NATALIE

WOLMAN LIVING TRUST; ALAN

BUDD ZUCKERMAN; JACK WALKER;

STEPHEN KAYE; THE MICHAEL S.

BARISH IRA; AND THE ALEXANDER

PERELBERG IRA,

Real Parties in Interest.

ORDER DENYING PETITION

This original petition for a writ of mandamus challenges a district court order denying a motion to dismiss.

Real parties in interest (RPIs) are minority shareholders in AeroGrow International. Inc. AeroGrow recently merged with SMG Supreme Court

OF

NevaDA {O} 19474 cfg

Growing Media, Inc. RPls filed a class action against petitioners, alleging breach of fiduciary duty and aiding and abetting breaches of fiduciary duty. Petitioners moved to dismiss RPIs’ amended complaint, arguing that the dissenters rights provision in NRS 92A.380 made appraisal RPIs’ exclusive remedy, precluding their complaint, and that the complaint failed to state a claim. The district court denied petitioners’ motion to dismiss, determining that RPIs adequately pleaded their claims. Petitioners reasserted their arguments in this writ petition, asserting that the district court erred by denying their motion to dismiss.

Petitioners have an adequate remedy at law

Petitioners argue that writ relief is warranted because they ft lack a plain, speedy, or adequate remedy at law. We disagree.

Whether to grant a mandamus relief petition is within this court’s sole discretion. Smith v. Eighth Judicial Dist. Court. 107 Nev. 674, is: H77, 818 P.2d 849, 851 GS91). A writ of mandamus may issue to compel the if performance of an act that the law requires or to control a district court’s arbitrary or capricious exercise ot discretion. NRS 34.160: Int'l Game Tech., Inc. v. Second Judicial Dist. Court, 124 Nev. 198, 197, 179 P.3d 556, 558 (2008). This extraordinary relief may be available if a petitioner does not have a plain, speedy, and adequate remedy otherwise. NRS 34.170.

Generally, this court declines to consider writ petitions challenging interlocutory orders denying motions to dismiss because an appeal from a final judgment is an adequate and speedy legal remedy. Int? Game Tech.., Nev. at 197, 179 P.8d at 558-59. Moreover, this court has made plain that it will only entertain such petitions when “no factual dispute exists and the district court is obligated to dismiss an action pursuant to clear Supreme Court

OF

Nevaba (O01 1987A eGR authority under a statute or rule....” Int’l Game Tech., 124 Nev. at 197- 98, 179 P.3d at 559.

We determine that writ relief is not warranted because petitioners have an adequate remedy through an appeal and this matter involves factual disputes better left for the district court. Petitioners may yet succeed by summary judgment after discovery has completed or at trial, and if they are unsuccessful on those fronts, they may appeal to this court. Additionally, the record demonstrates that trial is set for October 25, 2022. This expedited timeline further counsels our denial of this petition. Put simply, extraordinary relief is not warranted when the ordinary course of litigation will suffice.

There are factual disputes between the parties

Petitioners also argue that RPIs’ complaint did not adequately allege either basis set forth in NRS 92A.380(2), that the district court erred in concluding that two of the petitioners owed fiduciary duties to the minority stockholders, and that the district court’s conclusions imposing these duties on these parties were unsupported by the record.

Problematically, the parties vigorously contest the facts alleged in the complaint and the district court is best positioned to resolve this dispute. Petitioners have thus failed to show the absence of a factual dispute and that writ relief was appropriate on this basis.

There are no important tissues of law that need clarification Petitioners further contend that the petition will clarify when “stockholders may—-and may not---assert certain claims challenging the price of a merger outside the exclusive appraisal process set forth in NRS Chapter 92A.”

SuPREME Court

OF

Nevaba (0) 1947 aegSBpo

While this court may consider writ petitions where “an important issue of iaw needs clarification and considerations of sound judicial economy and administration militate in favor of granting the petition,” Intl Game Tech., 124 Nev. at 197-98, 179 P.3d at 559, this writ petition does not present any issues of law needing clarification. This court has clarified when dissenting shareholders fall under NRS 92A.380(2)’s exceptions. Cohen v. Mirage Resorts, Inc., 119 Nev. 1, 62 P.3d 720 (2003). And so, we conclude that writ relief is unwarranted on this ground as well.

Accordingly, we

ORDER the petition DENIED. pA, A Laat. , od.

Hardesty

Stiglich

Herndon cc: Hon. Mark R. Denton, District Judge

Jones Day/Atlanta

Pisanelhi Bice, PLLC

Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP/Las Vegas

Jones Day/Columbus

Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner LLP/Denver

Marquis Aurbach Coffing

Muehlbauer Law Office, Ltd.

Wolf Popper LLP

Kemp Jones, LLP

Bottini & Bottint, Inc.

Supreme Court

OF

NEVADA (0) 19474 aie

Snnons Hall Johnston PC/Reno

Eighth District Court Clerk

SupPREME COURT

OF

Nevapa (O) 19974 eSB

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.