In re the Judicial Accounting of Keogh
Cases that cite this one
25 later published cases cite this decision.
- Rhode Island Hospital Trust Company v. Otis (R.I. 1950)
- Chemical Bank & Trust Co. v. Streat (N.Y. 1933)
- In re the Estate of Meyer (New York Surrogate's Court 1931)
- In re Bahrenburg (New York Surrogate's Court 1924)
- In re the Judicial Settlement of the Account of Title Guarantee & Trust Co. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1913)
- In re the Accounting of Panish (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1968)
- Wyckoff v. Garrison (Court of Chancery of Delaware 1967)
- Wyckoff v. Garrison (Court of Chancery of Delaware 1967)
- In re the Estate of Sanford (New York Surrogate's Court 1957)
- In re the Accounting of Lincoln Rochester Trust Co. (New York Surrogate's Court 1948)
- In re the Construction of the Will of Sulima (New York Surrogate's Court 1948)
- In re the Accounting of Lincoln Rochester Trust Co. (New York Surrogate's Court 1948)
- In re the Estate of Stephani (New York Surrogate's Court 1936)
- Hawthorne v. Smith (New York Supreme Court 1935)
- In re the Transfer Tax upon the Estate of Kirby (New York Surrogate's Court 1928)
- Equitable Trust Co. v. Miller (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1921)
- In re the Final Judicial Settlement of the Account of Proceedings of Roest (New York Surrogate's Court 1916)
- In re the Judicial Settlement of the Account of the Title Guarantee & Trust Co. (New York Surrogate's Court 1913)
- Whitwell v. Whitwell (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1911)
- Lauter v. Hirsch (New York Supreme Court 1910)
- Lauter v. Hirsch (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 1910)
- Bayley v. Beekman (New York Supreme Court 1909)
- Kernochan v. Whitney (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1908)
- In re the Accounting of Keogh (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1908)
- In re the Final Judicial Settlement of the Accounts of Hoyt (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1906)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The testator, the construction of whose will is involved in this appeal, died January 17, 1881, leaving as his only surviving next of kin John J. Jones, a brother, and Mary J. Griffith, Susan J. Dannat, Jane J. Thayer and Margaret A. Jones, sisters. The particular paragraph of the will to be construed is as follows :
“Sixth. I give, devise and bequeath to the said "Wilson G. Hunt, Hamilton Blydenburg, Alexander Thayer and John J. Jones, Executors and Trustees as aforesaid, the remaining one equal fifth part of all my estate, real and personal (after payment-of debts and funeral expenses as aforesaid). To have and to. hold the same to them and the survivors and survivor of them for and during the life of my brother John J. J ones, in trust, nevertheless, to take possession of the real estate, keep the same in suitable and proper repair, keep the buildings thereon well insured and to let or lease • the same from time to time and for such terms of time within the lifetime of my said brother as to them may seem best and for the best rent that can be obtained therefor, -to keep the personal estate safely and securely invested and to collect the rents and profits of the real estate and the interest, dividends and income of the personal estate and after paying all taxes, assessments, expenses of repairs, insurance and all other legal and necessary charges and expenses pay over the residue or net proceeds of said remaining fifth part of my estate so given to them in trust as last aforesaid to my said brother John J. Jones semi-annually during his life, and immediately upon his death the said trustees, the survivors and survivor of .them shall grant, convey, transfer and'deliver over the said remaining one-fifth part of my estate so given to them in trust as last aforesaid and any income thereof remaining in their hands to the lawful children of my said brother in equal portions
In like language he creatéd four other trusts of the remaining four equal fifth parts, of his residuary estate for the benefit of each of his four sisters respectively, using the same language in the disposition of the remainders in each case. The brother John J. Jones died November 14,. 1904, leaving no descendants. The sister Margaret never married. The sister'Jane J. Thayer had seven children. The sister Mary J. Griffith had four-,children, one of whom pre.deceased the said brother John J. Jones, leaving no descendants, and the sister Susan J. Gannat had four children, one of whom predeceased the said brother John J. Jones, leaving two descendants.
Three questions are argued on this appeal, viz.: First, did the remainder of the trust estate for the. brother John J. Jones vest upon the death of the testator ? Second, in the division of said remainder did the testator intend equality among his nephews, and nieces, or equality among his sisters’ children by classes, each class including the child or children of a sister ? and, third, to whom did the accrued income not distributed at the time of the death of said John J. Jones pass ?
We think the learned surrogate correctly held that there was no vesting of the remainders until the time for distribution arrived, and his opinion (47 Misc. Rep. 37) is so satisfactory upon this point that we desire to add nothing to it. W.e do not agree, however, with the construction adopted respecting the division of the remainder. It may be granted that, in the absence of anything in the will evincing a contrary intent, the remaindermen would take equally, and it may also be assumed, that they would take equally but for the phrase “ the child or children of each to take an equal portion thereof,” but we think that this phrase when construed in the light .of the. manifest
As to the third question, W6 ’think thaf the conclusion of the learned surrogate, that the unpaid income accrued p'rior-to the death of" said John J. Jones passed to his personal representative, is correct. Although the will provided for semi-annual payments of income, in, the absence of anything to the contrary, it must be assumed that the testator intended the immediate vesting in the life beneficiary of all income upon its being paid in. (Smith v. Parsons, 146 N. Y. 116.) The postponement of'such vesting, for however s'hort'a time, would offend the statutes against unlawful accumulations. (1 R. S. 773, 774, §§ 3, 4, revised in Pers. Prop. Law [Laws of 1897, chap. 417], § 4; 1 R. S. 726, §§ 37, 38, revised in Real Prop. Law [Laws of 1896, chap. 547], § 51; Pray v. Hegeman, 92 N. Y. 508.) There is nothing in the will showing an intention to postpone the immediate vesting of income, unless"it be found in the Words “ together with- any income thereof remaining in their hands,” found in the provisiotis directing the distribution of the remainder upon the death of said John J. Jones. As the. learned ’surrogate remarked, those words may well refer to the .time of dis‘tfibution, for obviously the testator must have known, that some time must elapse between the death of Said John J. Jones and said
The decree should be modified to the extent of providing that the corpus of the trust estate created by the 6th paragraph of the will, together with all income thereon which has accrued subsequent to the death of the life beneficiary, be distributed among the nephews and nieces of the testator living at the time of the death of said life beneficiary, or to the personal representative of any since dying, in the following proportions: One equal third part thereof to the children of Mary J. Griffith; one equal third part thereof to the children of Susan J. Dannat; one equal third part thereof to the children of Jane J. Thayer, and as modified affirmed, with costs to all parties payable out of the estate.
Hirschberg, P. J., Jenks, Hooker and Rich, JJ., concurred.
Decree of the Surrogate’s Court of Westchester county modified in accordance with opinion of Miller, J., and as modified affirmed, with costs to all parties payable out of the estate. Order to be settled before Miller, J.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.