David Stevenson Brewing Co. v. Junction Realty Co.
Cases that cite this one
5 later published cases cite this decision.
- Meyers v. Knights of Pythias Bronx Temple Ass'n (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1920)
- Barrett v. First Nat. Bank of Green River (Wyo. 1936)
- Stafford Security Co. v. Kremer (City of New York Municipal Court 1930)
- Armstrong v. Shapiro (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1923)
- Terwilliger v. Browning, King & Co. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1915)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The evidence is by no means satisfactory that the written agreement to reduce the rent was accompanied by an oral condition which, being unfulfilled, rendered it inoperative. The
The lease was under seal, the agreement to reduce the rent was not. It is settled law that a contract or covenant under seal cannot be modified by a parol unexecuted agreement. (McKenzie v. Harrison, 120 N. Y. 260.) In this case the agreement to reduce the rent was never executed, in the sense in which that word is used in the statement of the rule, because it was never carried out. As was said in a recent case: ‘ ‘ While the agreement to reduce the rent remained unexecuted, it was void and inoperative. The lessors had the right to repudiate it at any time and demand the full amount of rent provided for in the lease.” (Zindler v. Levitt, 132 App. Div. 397.)
■ Furthermore, if a valid modification of the lease had" been made, the plaintiff could have raised the question as to the amount of' rent due in the Municipal Court under section 2244 of the Code of Civil Procedure as it now stands, and, therefore, a resort to equity was unnecessary.
The decision contains two conclusions of law (second and third) declaring what was the duty of the plaintiff with respect to the orders issued by the bureau of buildings and the tenement house department, and also declaring what rights accrued thereunder to the landlord. The case presented no issue regarding those matters which it Was necessary to decide, and it was improper to include these conclusions of law in the decision, since they might embarrass the plaintiff in other litigation in which the question might be involved. . To insure that no such result ' will follow, the judgment will be modified by striking out the words “ upon the merits,” leaving the judgment a mere dismissal of the complaint, and as so modified it will be affirmed, with costs.
Ingraham, P. J., McLaughlin and Clarke, JJ., concurred; Laughlin, J., dissented.
Dissenting Opinion
The defendant owned the premises known as No. 141 West Twenty-seventh street/upon which there were two buildings; one on the Twenty-seventh street front, and the other, a tene
Assuming that the contract for a modification of the rent rests in part in parol, I am of opinion that it was fully executed by the tenant, and that the landlord was not at liberty, after taking possession and proceeding with the demolition of the building with the consent of the tenant thus obtained, to recall the agreement and hold the tenant for the full amount of the rent prescribed by the lease. It is not necessary to decide the merits of the controversy as to whether the tenant was justified in preventing the demolition of the building by the landlord before an agreement had been made with respect to a reduction in the rent. The tenant apparently asserted that right in good faith and relinquished it upon the faith of the agreement subsequently made. I am of opinion that the rule of law that a parol agreement to reduce rent fixed by a lease under seal is void and inoperative in so far as it is unexecuted is not applicable to this case. That rule of course prevails where there is no consideration for the modification; but there is no authority, so far as I have been able to find, which holds that a landlord, by a parol agreement to reduce rent, may obtain the consent of the tenant of two buildings to remove one of them, and then under this rule repudiate the parol agreement as void and inoperative with respect to unpaid rent without, at least, restoring the tenant to the position in which he was before the agreement was made. If that rule be applicable it is a rule of law only, and a court of equity may and should, if necessary, enjoin the landlord from taking advantage of it. (See McKinley v. Hessen, 202 N. Y. 24.)
• A question, however, is involved, which is not free from doubt, and that is whether this was not available as a defense to the summary proceeding for the possession on account of the failure to pay more than the reduced rental. The learned trial court was of opinion that it was not so available, añd the ten
Judgment modified as directed in opinion, and as modified affirmed, with costs. Order to be settled on notice.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.