Waters of Saratoga Springs, Inc. v. State
Cases that cite this one
22 later published cases cite this decision.
- Chase Manhattan Bank, N.A. v. T & N PLC (District Court, S.D. New York 1995)
- Koch v. Christie's International PLC (2d Cir. 2012)
- Hunt v. Enzo Biochem, Inc. (District Court, S.D. New York 2006)
- Lessord v. General Electric Company (District Court, W.D. New York 2002)
- Carol Overall v. Estate of L.H.P. Klotz (2d Cir. 1995)
- Mills v. City Univ. of N.Y. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2018)
- Jeda Capital-Lenox, LLC v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2017)
- Jeda Capital-Lenox, LLC v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2017)
- Jeda Capital-Lenox, LLC v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2017)
- New York State Workers' Compensation Board v. Consolidated Risk Services, Inc. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2015)
- Richard A. Hutchens Cc v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2009)
- Lynch v. Carlozzi (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2001)
- Inter-Power of New York, Inc. v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1997)
- Bhagalia v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1996)
- Ghandour v. Shearson Lehman Bros. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1995)
- Hodge v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1995)
- Koffman v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1994)
- Anonymous v. Anonymous (New York Supreme Court 1992)
- TMG-II v. Price Waterhouse & Co. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1991)
- Burpee v. Burpee (New York Supreme Court 1991)
- Hoosac Valley Farmers Exchange, Inc. v. AG Assets, Inc. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1990)
- Lancaster Development, Inc. v. State (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1989)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Appeal from an order of the Court of Claims (Koreman, P. J.), entered December 24, 1984, which denied claimant’s application to deem its notice of intention to file a claim as a notice of claim and granted the State’s cross motions to dismiss the claim and the amended claim.
Claimant and the State Office of Parks and Recreation entered into a licensing agreement on June 29, 1978 whereby claimant obtained the right to bottle and market mineral water from springs and wells located on a State park in the City of Saratoga Springs, Saratoga County. In December 1981, the State Department of Health informed claimant that it was required to place certain warning labels on all bottled water sold after January 29, 1982. Claimant, believing that the warning label made the product unsaleable and, further, that
Initially, we hold that the Court of Claims was correct in denying claimant’s motion to deem its notice of intention as a claim. While the notice of intention was timely filed within six months of the accrual of the action (Court of Claims Act § 10 [4]), such a filing cannot hold open indefinitely the period within which to file a claim. It is readily apparent that the claim filed on April 23, 1984 was not presented within the two-year period mandated by Court of Claims Act § 10 (4). In order for a notice of intention to be treated as a claim, it must comply with the basic requirements of a claim (Patterson v State of New York, 54 AD2d 147, 149, affd 45 NY2d 885). It must allege all the necessary elements of a valid cause of action (Heisler v State of New York, 78 AD2d 767, 768). A careful reading of the allegations recited in the notice of intention reveals that they are addressed to the imposition of a labeling requirement by the Department of Health. Such action by the Department is sovereign activity and the State has not waived immunity with respect to such activities (see, Hodes v State of New York, 113 AD2d 121; Abruzzo v State of New York, 84 AD2d 876, 877). Accordingly, since the notice of intention fails to state a cause of action, the Court of Claims properly declined to treat it as a claim.
Turning to the claim and amended claim, it appears that they were filed beyond the two-year period prescribed by Court of Claims Act § 10 (4). However, claimant insists that causes of action are set forth therein which arose subsequent to the filing of the notice of intention. Specifically, claimant asserts that the amended claim contains allegations that constitute a breach of contract action which occurred within six months prior to the filing of the amended claim (Court of Claims Act § 10 [4]), as well as allegations constituting an action for fraud which was first discovered within 90 days of such filing (Court of Claims Act § 10 [3]).
In the first cause of action of the amended claim, claimant
Similarly, claimant’s second, third and fourth causes of action in the amended claim, alleging that the State breached various express and implied warranties in the licensing agreement, must be dismissed for the same reason. These warranty causes of action were not mentioned in claimant’s notice of intention. Accordingly, for the amended claim to be timely, it had to be filed within six months of accrual (Court of Claims Act § 10 [4]). The point of accrual of a claim under this statute is not identical to the time at which a cause of action accrues (see, Otis Elevator Co. v State of New York, 52 AD2d 380, 382). A claim accrues when damages accrue, i.e., when damages become ascertainable (supra). Here, claimant concedes that it ceased its bottling operation in January 1982. At this point claimant could have determined its damages. Thus, the breach of warranty actions were untimely.
We reach a like result in considering claimant’s fifth cause of action alleging that the State wrongfully removed claimant’s former president from the bottling plant on June 6, 1984. Since claimant had ceased operations 2 Vi years prior to the alleged wrongful removal, we cannot perceive any damages to claimant by reason of the State’s refusal to permit claimant’s officer to utilize the premises.
Turning to claimant’s sixth cause of action premised on the State’s alleged fraudulent representations, claimant contends that the State induced it to enter into the licensing agreement by supplying false information as to the quality and source of the mineral waters which were to be bottled. Claimant further alleges that this fraud was not discovered until February 28, 1984, thus arguing that the claim filed on April 23, 1984 was within 90 days of discovery. We disagree. The factual pattern set forth in the record persuades us that any fraud should have been discovered at a time proximate to the Department of Health’s imposition of the labeling requirement. The requisite label warned consumers that the water’s mineral content rendered it unfit as a sole source of drinking water. Thus, it was in 1982 that claimant became aware of the alleged
Having determined that the Court of Claims correctly refused to deem the notice of intention as a claim, and, further, that the April 23, 1984 claim as well as all six causes of action set forth in the August 23, 1984 amended claim were untimely, we affirm the Court of Claims order.
Order affirmed, with costs. Mahoney, P. J., Kane, Casey, Weiss and Levine, JJ., concur.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.