Nyack Nursing Home v. Dowling
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Residence v. Novello (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
OPINION OF THE COURT
Petitioner operates a residential health care facility and participates in the Federal/State Medicaid program (42 USC § 1396 et seq.). Under this program, residential health care facilities receive reimbursement for the services they provide to eligible patients in accordance with rates that are established on the basis of certain allowable costs (10 NYCRR 86-2.9 [a]). Sometime prior to 1986, the State Department of Health and/or Department of Social Services audited petitioner’s reported Medicaid costs for the rate years 1972 through 1981.
In 1987, respondent conducted an audit of petitioner’s Medicare Part B receipts for the 1984 and 1985 rate years.
Petitioner then commenced this combined CPLR article 78 proceeding and declaratory judgment action seeking, inter alia, a judgment annulling the ALJ’s determination along with a declaration of its contractual rights under the stipulation. Supreme Court, finding that the ALJ’s determination had a rational basis, dismissed the CPLR article 78 petition and denied petitioner’s request for declaratory judgment relief. This appeal ensued.
We shall first consider the propriety of Supreme Court’s dismissal of petitioner’s CPLR article 78 petition. As there was no
Turning to the declaratory judgment action, Supreme Court should not have summarily denied petitioner this relief because such an action is an appropriate vehicle for settling justiciable disputes pertaining to contract rights and obligations (see, Kalisch-Jarcho, Inc. v City of New York, 72 NY2d 727, 731; Abate v All-City Ins. Co., 214 AD2d 627, 629; Matter of Hertz v Rozzi, 148 AD2d 535, 536, affd 74 NY2d 702). Here, the focus of the parties’ dispute is respondent’s contention that, by providing in the stipulation that the adjustments would be made "if and when audits are performed”, the parties acknowledged that respondent has no obligation to conduct a rate reimbursement audit and that its timing is wholly within its discretion. Petitioner contends that this construction of the stipulation is irrational and renders it illusory, as it permits respondent to avoid making the adjustments for the return of equity by simply failing to perform a rate reimbursement audit. Accordingly, it argues that respondent should be directed to abide by the stipulation and that this matter should be remanded to respondent with a direction to conduct the requisite audit.
Generally, although Social Services Law § 368-c (2) requires respondent to conduct an on-site audit of residential health care facilities at least once every four years, a provider is not entitled to an order directing an audit (see, Matter of Mercy Health & Rehabilitation Ctr. v Dowling, 233 AD2d 901, 902). This case differs from the usual circumstance in that respondent has contractually recognized that petitioner is entitled to
Ordered that the judgment is modified, on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as denied petitioner’s request for declaratory relief; matter remitted to the Supreme Court for further proceedings not inconsistent with this Court’s decision; and, as so modified, affirmed.
. Effective April 1, 1983, the authority to audit residential health care facilities was transferred from the Department of Health to the Department of Social Services (L 1983, ch 83, §§ 9,13).
. Medicare Part B is a supplementary medical insurance program for aged and disabled persons that is financed from premium payments by the enrollees and the Federal Government (42 USC § 1395j).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.