Mitchell v. Calle
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- Ayala v. Cruz (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
- Genao v. Delacruz (New York Supreme Court, New York County 2024)
- Deneen v. Bucknor (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2019)
- Wenegieme v. Harriott (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2018)
- Marin v. Belabe (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 2018)
- FTBK Investor II LLC v. Genesis Holding LLC (New York Supreme Court 2014)
- Collazo v. Anderson (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2013)
- Collazo v. Anderson (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2013)
- Delgado v. Papert Transit, Inc. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
- Duran v. Kabir (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
- Thompkins v. Ortiz (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
- James v. Perez (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
- Jeffers v. Styte Transit Inc. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
- Jeffers v. Styte Transit Inc. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2012)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Defendants concede that plaintiff has a meniscal tear in her left knee, and their radiologist’s report is too equivocal to make a prima facie showing that the tear was not caused by the accident (see Glynn v Hopkins, 55 AD3d 498, 498 [2008]), especially given plaintiffs relatively young age at the time of the accident (see June v Akhtar, 62 AD3d 427, 428 [2009]). However, defendants made a prima facie showing that plaintiff did not sustain a “permanent consequential limitation of use” of the knee within the meaning of Insurance Law § 5102 (d) by submitting the affirmed reports of medical experts who opined that she had normal range of motion in the knee and that any symptoms had fully resolved (see Dembele v Cambisaca, 59 AD3d 352, 352 [2009]; Gibbs v Hee Hong, 63 AD3d 559, 559 [2009]). The affirmed reports are competent evidence, notwithstanding that the experts relied on the uncertified emergency room records and other unsworn medical records (see Pommells v Perez, 4 NY3d 566, 577 n 5 [2005]).
In response, plaintiff submitted the affirmed reports of her treating physiatrist and the orthopedic surgeon who performed her knee surgery, who both found persisting limitations in range of motion of the left knee with discomfort, and described the qualitative nature of plaintiffs limitations based on the normal function, purpose, and use of the knee. In addition, plaintiff submitted an unsworn MRI report of the left knee stating that there was a small effusion suggesting a meniscal tear. Plaintiffs evidence raised an issue of fact as to whether she sustained a permanent consequential limitation of use of the knee (see Toure v Avis Rent A Car Sys., 98 NY2d 345 [2002]; Salman v Rosario,
The court, however, should have dismissed the 90/180-day claim. Defendants made a prima facie showing that plaintiff did not suffer a 90/180-day injury, and plaintiff failed to raise a triable issue of fact. Indeed, plaintiff testified that, after the accident, she was confined to bed for only three days and to home for a only week (see Salman, 87 AD3d at 484). Further, the claimed restrictions in her usual and customary activities are unsupported by objective medical evidence (see Nelson v Distant, 308 AD2d 338, 340 [2003]).
We have considered defendants’ remaining contentions and find them unavailing. Concur — Mazzarelli, J.P., Friedman, Catterson, Renwick and Freedman, JJ.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.