New York Court of Common Pleas, 1853

Schwartz v. Bendel

Schwartz v. Bendel
New York Court of Common Pleas · Decided May 15, 1853 · Woodruff
2 E.D. Smith 123
Schwartz v. Bendel

Opinion of the Court

By the Court. Woodruff, J.

The notice of appeal in this case assigns no grounds therefor. The statute is explicit on this subject, (Code, § 353,) and we should be warranted in dismissing the appeal upon this ground.

I have, nevertheless, looked at the defendant’s affidavit, which was submitted to us with the return, and I find it there stated, that the ground of appeal is, that the judgment was rendered upon insufficient evidence, and against the weight of evidence. I think this has no just foundation.

*124It is plainly a case in which the finding of the court below should be sustained.

We have not examined the other affidavits submitted, for the reason that we have no power to order a new trial, on the ground that the defendant has discovered further evidence.

The judgment must be affirmed, with costs.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.