New York Court of Common Pleas, 1862

Smith v. Douglass

Smith v. Douglass
New York Court of Common Pleas · Decided August 15, 1862 · Hilton
15 Abb. Pr. 266

Counsel

George W. Parsons, for the motion., Peter Y. Cutler, opposed.

Smith v. Douglass

Opinion of the Court

Hilton, J.

Although I think it quite probable that the plain*271tiff, at the trial, will present but one cause of action, yet, I do not perceive that because of that probability I would be justified in striking out several distinct causes which are properly alleged in his complaint.

It seems to me, that granting the present motion would be in effect determining before trial, and upon mere suspicion, that the plaintiff has not certain causes of action against the defendant, notwithstanding those causes have been averred in the forms recognized as sufficient in pleading.

Motion denied. Costs to abide event. a

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.