Pennsylvania Steel Co. v. New York City Ry. Co.
Opinion of the Court
No attempt will be made to restate the extremely complicated series of questions which have been presented in this proceeding. Such of the special master’s conclusions as have been controverted on the argument will be taken up in convenient, although perhaps not in logical sequence.
Claim Against Metropolitan.
1. It is contended that the amount of damages allowed for failure to keep rolling stock, other than the motors and electric equipment in good working order ($81,047.94), should be materially increased. There was a wide discrepancy between the experts as to the cost on November 18, 1908, of thus repairing the closed cars then turned over to claimant. This discrepancy is due in part to different assumptions by the experts as to the condition in which the cars then were. The testimony of the witnesses has been read and I see no reason to find that there was any mnsterial difference in condition between these cars thus turned over and the general run of cars of the same age in use in the system, and concur with the master’s finding that the estimate of the man who had some real knowledge of their condition at that time is the more satisfactory.
2. As to the refusal to allow damages for the loss of the car barn by fire on February 29, 1908, the master’s conclusion that under prior decisions of the Circuit Court of Appeals in these proceedings show such allowance cannot be made is concurred in.
6. As to the item of $6,410.39 construction charges the master’s findings and conclusions are confirmed.
7. The next item is $750,000 (power house contract) credited to Metropolitan against debits for bonds turned over for expenditures in change of motive power and reconstruction. In his first opinion the master thought it unnecessary to pass upon this item. It was used only as a set off or credit against the amount of debits charged against the Metropolitan on bond account. Inasmuch, however, as he found for respondent as to items 3 and 4, supra, there was no excess of debits over other proved credits which made it necessary to consider this setoff. In a supplementary report he did dispose of it; why is not entirely clear, as he did not change his conclusions as to items 3 and 4.
It seems clear enough that under the lease, which expressly provided for change of motive power, the building of a power house was a legitimate part of such change. Instead of building one, a contract was made between the two roads by which in consideration of $750,000 in bonds the Metropolitan agreed not only to furnish power for Second Avenue system from its own power house while the lease lasted, to run the road, which it would have to do anyhow, but also in case the lease should terminate, jand the Second Avenue Company resume possession or' the mortgage should be foreclosed, to continue to furnish power for the system for the unexpired term of the charter of the Second Avenue Company and any renewals thereof. This contract must be tested by conditions existing when it was made, when every one expected the Metropolitan would continue a solvent concern. I agree with the special master that the contract cannot be held fraudulent and void in its inception. If the price was exorbitant equity might scale it down, but if the master’s conclusions were erroneous as to items 3, 4, and 5, the balance against Metropolitan on the bond account would be but $114,930.56 and the power house contract at the time it was made must certainly have been worth that amount.
The exceptions to the report on the claim against Metropolitan Company are overruled and the report confirmed — except possibly as to the $23,850, accrued interest referred to above.
Claim Against City Railway.
Substantially all the propositions involved in the disposition of this claim depend upon the scope and meaning of various prior deliverances of the Court of Appeals in opinions filed upon the decision of appeals taken in other proceedings involved in this receivership. That tribunal would be in no way assisted towards the disposition of the appeal in this proceeding by a statement of the interpretation of those deliverances which seems to this court, to be the correct one or of the reasons which lead to such a conclusion. It knows better than the special master or tito District Court precisely what legal propositions are contained in those opinions. It is enough to say that,, generally, the views of the special master are concurred in.
The exceptions are overruled and the report confirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.