Navarro Zavala v. Trece Corp.

District Court, S.D. New York

Navarro Zavala v. Trece Corp.

Trial Court Opinion

UNITESDT ATDEISS TRCIOCUTR T SOUTEHRND ISTROIFCN TE WY ORK CLAUDINOA VARZRAOV ALiAn,d ividually anodnb ehoaoflft hseirmsi sliatrulayt ed, Pliantiff, -against- ORDER TRECCEO RPd.o,ib nugs iansTe rseMsce ex ican 18C i1v3.8 (2E R) Resta5u4Er AaSnETtN ,T ERITNAMEMNGTT INCd.o ibnugs iansTe rseMsce ex iRceasnt aurant, anJdO ELLI M, Defendants. RAMOS,D .J.: ClauNdaivoaZ rarvoba rloau tghahictst iiFnoe nb r2u0a1ar8gy a TirnesCctoe r 5p4. , EaEsntt ertMaGiT,nmI enancnt.Jd o Leilmfo ,ru npoaviedr wtaigmueens d tehFrea Liarb or StanAdca(tr" dFsL SaAnN"de) Yw o rkL abLoar(w " NYLvLi"o)l;oa fmt iinoinwm augme proviusnidFoeLnrSsa A n NdY LLv;i oloafnt oitorinec ceo,r daknewdea pgsietn agt,e ment requiruenmdteehnNretY sL La;nu dm eimbeuqrusiepcdmo esuntntsdt ehFreL SaAn NdY LL. CompDlo.c1,..P nedibnegf tohrCeeo uirtsth p ea rtaipepsl'if cocarot uiaroptnp rooftv haeli r SettlAegmreenetDm oecn5.t2 .. Int hCiisr cpuairctta,in epnsro itv saettFetLllSyceA l awiimptsrh ejaubdsitechneet approoftv hadeli sctoruiorcrttt hD ee parotfLm aebnCothr .ev eF.kr se ePpaonrctHa okues e, In7c9.F,63. d1 9290,(02 Cdi 2r0.1 T5h)pe.a rtthieersme ufossrtae t tihsCefyo utrhtta hte ir agreeim"sef naatnir dre asonBaebclkveRe..or "nt i ruNbo1i.5nC oi1vv9,.5 ( 1P A2E0)1W,5L 8773a4*t61 (0 S,. YD D.eNc1..4 2, 0 1"5I)dn.e terwmhientithnhpegerr o psoestetdli esm ent faiarn rde asoanc aobuslrheto,c u olnds tihtdeoe troa fcl iirtcyu misntcalnbucudentiso n,tg limtitoth efoedl lofawcitnog(r 1ts)h:p e l airnatniogfffpe' o ss sriebcloe(v 2et)rhe yex; t teon t whi'cthsh eet tlweiemlnelan tbthl peea rttaoiv eosai ndt icbiupradateneenddxs p einns es estabtlhireseihsrip necgcl taaiinvmddese fen;s( e3ts)hs' ee riooufts hnleei stsir giasfatkciseo dn byt hpea rt(4i )we hse;t 'hteshree t tlaegmreeneitmts eh pnert o doufac rtm 's-blaernggatihn ing betweexepne riceonucnaesnde(d l5 t')h;p e o ssiobffri aluoidrct oyl luIsd.i( oqnu.o"t ing WolivnS.sc kyh olIans9ct0.Fi0,S.c u p2pd3. 3 323,(5 S .D.2N0.1Y2C.)o )u.mr atryse jae ct propFoLsSesAde ttlwehmeetrnhepte a rdtoin eopstr ovtihbdeae sf iotsrh r ee cofviegrouyrr e documenstuaptpiotorhnrte ei ansgo naobftl haeetn teosrnfesee ysos,rt' hs ee ttlaegmreenetm ent incliumdpeesr mpirsosviibssluiecao hsrn ess trciocnfitdievnetc ilaaluoisrote vyse rbroad releLaosepvseN..zi gohCftasb iLrLiC9a,6F, S. u p3pd1. 7 107,6 -(8S2. D.2N0.1cY5.i) t,e d wiatphp rioCnvh aele7 ks9F,6. a32td0 5-06. HerNea,v aZrarvoha alcsaa lcutlhahatewte o dr kjeuodsv te1 r1 ,h6o0u0frr osm Decem2b0e1tr3oD ecem2b0e1rD7 o.c5 .2E x2..N avaZrarvoaa lllaet ghteahstde e fendants failteopd a hyi amtt h oev errtaiotmf1ee . t5i mheirsse guwlaagforera noyfh iosv erhtoiumres . Hea lcsloa liimqsu iddaamtaepgdee nsa,l atnuidne rse,i mcbousrNtsasev.da Z rarvoea sltai mates tha"tih,feh arde covienfur lfelod hr ic sl aihmews o,u"rl edc oavbeo$ru1 t9 6i,nd5 a0m0a ges, penalatniidne tse,Tr hedese tfe.n dhaanvpters o druecceodtr hmdaastdy i sptuhateme o uonft houNrasv aZrraov acllaah iemw so rakn,td h tew coo rpodreafetnedh aanvfteis lf eodr bankrpuopttecnyct,oi maplllicyco altlieoncnagtj iuodng mFelonlto.wa mi endgi aitni on Octo2b0e1tr9h p,ea ratgiretessoe edt NtalveaZ rarvoa cllaa'fisoma rts o toaf$l 3 7,5O0ft0 h.a t amouNnatv,aZ rarvowa oluarl edc e$i2v5e,a 0ft0ea0rt tornfeeyaesnsc'd o sItnls i.go hftt h e partsiuebsm'i sasntidho reni ssa kncsdo sotfls i titghaetisisenst guot e rsit ahCleo, u crotn cludes thtahtpe a rtpireosp'so estetdl aemmoeuonnf$tt 3 7,i5fas0i 0ar n rde asounnadbtelhree circumsSteaGena crevcGs.i.o a o fdoL rif bey8 1I,n Nco.1.,7C i0v7.2 (2B8C M2)0,1WL 8 3559a1t*72 1( ,S .D.JNu.1lY2y2., 0 1(8c)o nctlhutdahitsen e gt tlaemmoeurnnettfl eac ted "reascoonmapbrloeom fdi issepi ustseude s"). Asn otNeadv,a Zrarvosa tlaatt hehasewt o urledc e$i2v5e,fr 0o0mt0 h see ttlfuenmde,n t anhdi cso unwsoeulrl edc e$i1v2e,w 5h0i0rc,eh p reosneen-totsfth ihtreod ts aelt tlement amou1n "t[.C]oiuntr hDtiisss trroiucttai wnaeorlndyte h irasd e totfl fuenmdae san tr easonable feei nF LScAa sNeosn.e theevlewenhs etsnh,p e r opfeoesdseo d enxocteo entdeh iorftd h e totsaelt tlaemmoeucnnottu ,ir ntth sci isr ucsuteih lteo demsettaharosa dc rocshset coek n sure three asonaobfal tetnoernfeseesys Ls.'a" zv Ko.i smN aialtYs o ArvkeI .n,Nc o.1.,7C i3v3.0 2 (AJ2N0)1,W9 L 9 56a38t*,2 ( S.D.JNa2.n2,Y.0 1(9c)i toamtiitotne d). "Thleo deasmtoauirn's tt p hreo doufacr te asohnoaubrrlaleaty ne td h ree asonable numboefhr o urresq ubiytr heceda seI.d.(q" u'o tGianiHgao uMseezL zL vCS. t aSttBe.a n&k TrC.o N.o,1. 1C i3v1.8 260,1W 4L3 915758a,t* 1( S.D.ANu.g1Y.32. ,0 14H)e)rN.ea ,v arro Zavhaalssau bmitthbteie ldl infogr tr weoocfh o iarstd tso rnmeaynsa,gm ienmgbM eirc hael Fiallwahcboei ,al $tl 4s5 p0eh ro uarn,ad s soJceisaBstaeer twohnbo,i al$tl 3s7 p5eh ro uSre.e Doc5.2a 3tE, x 3..A lthotuhageth t ornreayt"sea'sor net hhei gehno dfw haitts y piinFcL aSlA caseLso,pv"eP. zl oDye eI,nN co.1.,5 C6i4(v7A. J 2N0)1,W6 L 1 626a6*t314 (, S .D.ANp.rY.. 212,0 1t6h)e,y w iatrthehi en orfra negaes ohnoaubrrlaletfoy er ss i mielxaprelryi enced attornseeRyeos d,r ivg3.u5 e5Rz1e aClotyN. o,1. 7C i6v5.5 230,1W 7L5 054a7t*2 38 , (S.D.NNo.v2Y.,2 0 1(7s)t atthaialnttg h hoouugrrhal toye f$s 4 5fo0rp artanne$dr3 s5fo 0r assoc"iaasrtoeem se whhiagtth hetarhn p er esumrpetaisvoernlaaytib entlsh eD i iss ttrhiaecryte , nobte yotnhpdea lRe"e)d;z evpH.aa gmimcNe or1.,4C i9v8.0 (8E R2)0,1W 7L1 951a86*t52 , n.(2S .D.MNa.y8Y ,2 0 1(7a)p prroavotif$en 5 g0p 0eh ro uforra n ampeadr tThneesrre)a .t es, antdh 1e6 h.o4u orfws o rrke asosnpaeobnnltt yh c iassy ei,ea ll odd eosf$t 6a5r2C 8o.st tost al $1272. Thleo deosf$t 6a4r2 8, ctootm hrpeea qrueeds teodft h$se1e 1t,t2ln2eeo8mtfc e onstt s, resiunall tosd emsutlatri polfif eereo sfa() pn perto xi17m..a" t[eAml]uy l tinpel2asi rhe oru ld, inm oscta sbeess u,ffi ccioemnpte nfosrat thrieio asnsk s ocwiiatcthoe ndt ifenegisenF n LtS A caseFsu.j"i vwS.au rsaYh ais Lutdd.5a8, F S.u p3pd4. 2 443,(9S .D.2N0.1Y4A.)c c.o rdingly, 1" [W]haesns etshsreie nags onoafab nla etnteosfrnseeo eynt ' hbsea soifis tp se rceonftt hsaeeg tet lieitms e nt, fairtelor o totokh pee rceonftt hsaeeg tet lneeomtcfe o nstMt so.n"t aAlrvkoIa nrvNc .o.1 .,7C i6v6.9( 3A JN), 201WL82 1864a1*t52 (, S .DM.aNy1. 0Y2,.0 1(8e)m phaadsdiesd ). the Court accepts the multiplier of 1.7 and determines $11,288 in attorneys’ fees to be reasonable under the circumstances. The requested costs of $1272 are also reasonable. With respect to Navarro Zavala’s obligations under the Agreement, they include no objectionable confidentiality provisions, and his release is appropriately limited to “claims in the Litigation that have occurred as of the Effective Date of this Agreement.” Doc. 52 Ex. 1 § 2; see Nights of Cabiria, 96 F. Supp. 3d at 177-81. Accordingly, the parties’ request for approval of the Agreement is GRANTED. The Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to terminate the motion, Doc. 52, and close the case.

It is SO ORDERED.

Dated: February 13, 2020 New York, New York

EDGARDO Ramos, U.S.D.J.

Reference

Status
Unknown