Cosby v. Commissioner of Social Security
Trial Court Opinion
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
________________________ NIKITA N. C.,
Plaintiff, v. Civil Action No.
5:20-CV-0225 (DEP) COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL SECURITY,
Defendant. __________________________ APPEARANCES: OF COUNSEL:
FOR PLAINTIFF OLINSKY LAW GROUP HOWARD D. OLINSKY, ESQ 250 South Clinton Street MELISSA DELGEURICO, ESQ. Suite 210 Syracuse, NY 13202 FOR DEFENDANT SOCIAL SECURITY ADMIN. HUGH RAPPAPORT, ESQ. J.F.K. Federal Building Room 625
New Sudbury Street Boston, MA 02203 DAVID E. PEEBLES U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE
ORDER
Currently pending before the court in this action, in which plaintiff seeks judicial review of an adverse administrative determination by the Commissioner of Social Security (“Commissioner”), pursuant to 42 U.S.C. §§ 405(g) and 1383(c)(3), are cross-motions for judgment on the pleadings.1 Oral argument was heard in connection with those motions on April 15, 2021, during a telephone conference conducted on the record. At the close of argument, I issued a bench decision in which, after applying the requisite deferential review standard, I found that the Commissioner=s determination resulted from the application of proper legal principles and is supported by substantial evidence, providing further detail regarding my reasoning and addressing the specific issues raised by the plaintiff in this appeal.
After due deliberation, and based upon the court=s oral bench decision, which has been transcribed, is attached to this order, and is incorporated herein by reference, it is hereby
ORDERED, as follows:
1) Defendant=s motion for judgment on the pleadings is 1 This matter, which is before me on consent of the parties pursuant to 28 U.S.C. ' 636(c), has been treated in accordance with the procedures set forth in General Order No. 18. Under that General Order once issue has been joined, an action such as this is considered procedurally, as if cross-motions for judgment on the pleadings had been filed pursuant to Rule 12(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
GRANTED.
2) |The Commissioner’s determination that the plaintiff was not disabled at the relevant times, and thus is not entitled to benefits under the Social Security Act, is AFFIRMED.
3) The clerk is respectfully directed to enter judgment, based upon this determination, DISMISSING plaintiff's complaint in its entirety.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Dated: April 20, 2021
Syracuse, NY UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK *************************************************** NIKITA N. COSBY, *
Plaintiff, * -v- 20-cv-225 *
COMMISSIONER OF SOCIAL SECURITY, *
Defendant. * ***************************************************
TRANSCRIPT OF TELECONFERENCE BEFORE THE HONORABLE DAVID E. PEEBLES
April 15, 2021 FOR THE PLAINTIFF:
MELISSA A. DELGUERCIO, ESQ.
250 South Clinton Street Syracuse, New York 13202 FOR THE DEFENDANT:
HUGH RAPPAPORT, ESQ.
New Sudbury Street Boston, Massachusetts 02203
COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 THE COURT: Plaintiff has commenced this proceeding pursuant to 42 United States Code, Sections 405(g) and 1383(c)(3) to challenge an adverse determination by the Commissioner of Social Security.
The background is as follows:
Plaintiff was born in October of 1976 and is currently 44 years of age. She was 37-years-old at the time of the amended onset date attributed to her disability, that being May 22, 2014.
Plaintiff is 5 foot, 11 inches in height and has weighed at various times between 234 and 270 pounds.
The record is somewhat ambiguous as to plaintiff's living conditions. At one point she was living with a girlfriend in an apartment, and at another point it was reported that she was homeless.
Plaintiff has an 11th grade education and was in special education classes while in school. She also has some sort of certifications in hotel management and cooking. Plaintiff is left-handed and has a driver's license.
I have to say before I go further that the record in this case was extremely poorly developed, but I note that plaintiff was represented, and without diminishing the administrative law judge's obligation to flesh out the record, ultimately, it is plaintiff's
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 burden to demonstrate her conditions and the resulting limitations associated with those conditions.
Plaintiff stopped working in January of 2011. Her prior work consists of and includes as a clothing sorter, a janitor, a groundskeeper, a babysitter, and in some position in a blacktop/landscape operation where she did flagging, among other things.
Physically, plaintiff suffers from Type 2 diabetes and resulting neuropathy, as well as asthma, for which she uses an inhaler and nebulizer, a lumbar back issue with reported pain extending into her legs, and pain and carpal tunnel syndrome possibly in her hands.
Plaintiff underwent stomach surgery in 2013 and groin surgery in 2005. Plaintiff reportedly was involved in a motor vehicle accident on July 6th, 2013. She has had both magnetic resonance imaging, or MRI, testing of her back and x-rays.
On July 28th, 2013, MRI testing revealed a small posterior central disc protrusion at L4-L5 and L5-S1, not causing significant central spinal canal stenosis; that appears at page 529 of the administrative transcript.
On July 21, 2016, MRI testing reflected minimal degenerative disc disease L4 -- L3-L4, very
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 small midline posterior L3-L4 disc protrusion extending only 2 millimeters into the spinal canal, and mild degenerative disc disease L5-S1, mild blood-based posterior L5-S1 disc protrusion extending only 3 millimeters into the spinal canal. The results of that testing appear at 1028 and 1029 of the administrative transcript.
X-rays taken on July 19, 2016, revealed mild degenerative changes L5-S1 and mild bilateral degenerative changes SI joints. That report appears at 1121 of the administrative transcript.
Mentally, plaintiff has suffered from reported anxiety and depression. For mental condition, she has undergone counseling with Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner Ann Sweet. She has not undergone any hospitalization. Plaintiff's primary care provider was or is Dr. Joseph Merola. She also has treated at the Joslin Center including with Dr. Barbara Mols-Kowalczewski, as well as Upstate, where she has seen Dr. Burk Jubelt and a resident, Dr. Sanam Anwer. She has also treated with St. Joseph's Family Medical with P.A. Joseph Morabito and Syracuse Orthopedics, or SOS, with Dr. Richard DiStefano.
Plaintiff has been prescribed various medications, including Lyrica, oxycodone, gabapentin,
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225
Cymbalta, Neurontin, Prazosin, Trazodone, Buspirone, and Wellbutrin.
Plaintiff's activities of daily living have included dressing; bathing; grooming; cooking, which she likes to do and does fairly often; housework, some; shopping, some; no dishes; no laundry. She takes public transportation. She drives, she reads, plays sports, gets along well with people, went on a Bahamas cruise in February of 2016; attends family cookouts, likes to fish, and wants to open a restaurant and exercises.
In 2013, plaintiff was apparently arrested for driving while intoxicated and underwent subsequent drug treatment as reflected at 12-F and 16-F. She is also a regular user of marijuana, and by that I mean the record reflects she uses marijuana as often as two to three times daily.
Procedurally, plaintiff applied for Title 16, Supplemental Security Income payments on May 22nd, 2014, alleging an onset date of December 31, 2010. That was later amended to May 22, 2013. She claimed disability based on diabetes, asthma, a learning disability, drug and alcohol problems, and back injury. I note that that followed a prior adverse administrative law judge decision on March 22, 2013.
A hearing was conducted by Administrative Law
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225
Judge Bruce S. Fein on July 28, 2016, to address plaintiff's request for SSI benefits. ALJ Fein issued an adverse decision on September 19th, 2016. The matter was subsequently remanded by the Social Security Administration Appeals Council on January 17th, 2018, with a directive that vocational expert testimony be elicited to determine the extent of any erosion of the job base on which the medical-vocational guidelines are predicated, and also to adequately consider plaintiff's obesity.
A second hearing was conducted on
November 6th, 2018. ALJ Fein issued another decision on January 24, 2019; also unfavorable to the plaintiff.
The Social Security Administration Appeals Council denied review of that decision on December 30, 2019, making the administrative law judge's opinion the final determination of the agency.
This action was commenced on February 28th, 2020, and is timely.
In his decision, ALJ Fein applied the familiar five-step sequential test for determining disability. He concluded at step one that plaintiff had not engaged in substantial gainful activities since May 22, 2014, although he noted that there had -- there was some work that was performed by the plaintiff after that date.
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 At step two, ALJ Fein concluded the plaintiff does suffer from impairments that are severe in that they provide more than a minimal limitation on plaintiff's ability to perform basic work functions, including low back pain with bilateral sciatica, neuropathy, post-traumatic stress disorder, depressive disorder, and anxiety disorder.
At step three, the administrative law judge concluded the plaintiff's conditions do not meet or medically equal any of the listed presumptively disabling conditions set forth in the commissioner's regulations, specifically considering listings 1.04, 11.13, 12.04, 12.06, 12.15.
The administrative law judge next concluded that notwithstanding her conditions, plaintiff maintained her residual functional capacity, or RFC, to perform light work subject to both physical and mental limitations.
Physically, he found the plaintiff cannot crawl or climb ladders, ropes, or scaffolds and can only occasionally climb ramps and stairs, balance, stoop, kneel and crouch.
He also found that claimant should also avoid concentrated exposure to operational control of moving machinery, unprotected heights, and hazardous machinery.
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 Mentally, he found that the claimant is limited to performing simple routine repetitive tasks. She also requires a low-stress job, which is defined as involving only occasional decision making, occasional use of judgment, and occasional changes in work setting.
At step four, Administrative Law Judge Fein concluded that plaintiff did not have any past relevant work to examine and proceeded to step five.
At step five, he first noted that if plaintiff were capable of performing a full range of light work, a finding of no disability would be required by consideration of the medical-vocational guidelines or grids set forth in the commissioner's regulations, specifically citing Grid Rule 202.17.
Considering the testimony of the vocational expert and the issue of erosion based on exertional and nonexertional limitations, ALJ Fein concluded the plaintiff is capable of performing in positions that are available in the national workforce, and representative examples included laundry folder, label coder and marker, and concluded plaintiff, therefore, was not disabled at relevant times and ineligible for the benefits sought.
As the commissioner rightfully argues, the test that the Court must apply in this case is
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 extremely deferential. I must determine whether correct legal principles were applied and the resulting determination is supported by substantial evidence, which is defined as such relevant evidence as a reasonable mind would consider adequate to support a conclusion.
As the Second Circuit has noted in Brault versus Social Security Administration Commissioner, 683 F.3d 443, 2012, the standard is extremely rigid. It is even more deferential than the clearly erroneous standard that orders are familiar with.
The Second Circuit additionally noted in Brault that the standard means that once an ALJ finds a fact, that fact can be rejected only if a reasonable fact finder would have to conclude otherwise.
The plaintiff in this case raises two basic contentions. The first concerns the physical components of the residual functional capacity and specifically centers upon the amount of weight afforded to Dr. Anwer's and Dr. Jubelt's medical source statement. The second addresses the mental components of the RFC and again focuses on improper weight given to the opinion of Nurse Practitioner Sweet, signed off on by Dr. Walia and also supported, in plaintiff's view, by Dr. Caldwell and Dr. Kahn.
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 Before I address those contentions, I noted one additional error. The hypothetical that was posed to the vocational expert did not exactly mirror the residual functional capacity finding in that it did not include the limitation of only occasional climb ramps or stairs, balance, stoop, kneel and crouch.
And so, I examined that issue, although it may well have been an issue that is waived by the plaintiff since it is not raised. It turns out that when you review the Dictionary of Occupational Titles, in two of the three exemplary positions cited, there's no climbing, balancing, stooping, kneeling, and crouching required and that would be true of the folder, which is a Dictionary of Occupational Titles 369.687-018, appearing at Westlaw -- 1991 Westlaw 673072. It's also true of the position of marker, that's Dictionary of Occupational Titles 209.587-034 appearing at 1991 Westlaw 671802, and the third one, label coder, which appears at Dictionary of Occupational Title 920.587-014, reported at 1991 Westlaw 687915, there is occasional climbing required, and occasional stooping required, but then again, that is consistent with the residual functional capacity finding.
So, I find that there was no error or, at best, it is harmless error. Turning to the physical
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 component of the residual functional capacity, as a backdrop, let me note that one of the primary functions and pivotal to a consideration of a disability claim is determination of residual functional capacity, which represents a finding of the range of tasks that a claimant is capable of performing, notwithstanding his or her impairments, 20 CFR Section 40 -- in this case 416.945, and Tankisi versus Commissioner of Social Security, 521 F.App'x 29 from the Second Circuit 2013.
An RFC determination of course is informed by the consideration of all of the relevant medical and other evidence.
The administrative law judge's RFC finding of course must be supported by substantial evidence. As a backdrop also, I note that under Poupore from the Second Circuit, it is plaintiff's burden to establish her limitations up through step four, including at the RFC stage.
One of the issues -- key issues raised with regard to the physical components of the RFC finding is considerations of the medical source statement of Resident Dr. Anwer, signed off on by Dr. Jubelt, dated April 20, 2016. It appears at pages 641 through 644 of the administrative transcript.
After identifying symptoms that the plaintiff
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 would experience, Dr. Anwer and Dr. Jubelt were asked to opine concerning sitting, standing, and walking at page 642. The result is quite ambiguous. There are two columns intended for checkmarks. There are no checkmarks. Instead, the doctors have circled about four hours without indication of whether that is cumulative of sitting, standing, walking, or whether it applies to each category.
The opinion goes on to state that plaintiff can occasionally lift 10 pounds and less than 10 pounds, and also opines that plaintiff would be off task more than 20 percent of the time and absent more than four days per month. That opinion was discussed by the administrative law judge and -- at page 31 and given little weight.
The administrative law judge noted that plaintiff had only treated with those physicians for two months, that it was inconsistent with plaintiff's activities of daily living and inconsistent with plaintiff's hearing testimony, particularly with regard to lifting.
I note first that these individuals are properly regarded as treating sources. The opinion of the treating source regarding the nature and severity of an impairment is entitled to considerable deference if
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 it is supported by medically acceptable clinical and laboratory diagnostic techniques and is not inconsistent with other medical evidence; Veino versus Barnhart, 312 F.3d 578, Second Circuit 2002.
Treating source opinions are not controlling, however, if they are contrary to other substantial evidence in the record, including the opinions of other medical experts.
Of course where there are conflicts in the form of contradictory medical evidence, the resolution is properly entrusted to the commissioner under Veino.
The administrative law judge is not giving controlling weight to attributing source opinion must detail what degree of weight, if any, should be assigned to the opinion and consider the relevant factors set out in 20 CFR Section 416.927, sometimes referred to as the Burgess factors in this case, and I note, of course, that this case is being decided under the former regulations governing medical opinions because this claim was filed prior to March of 2017.
In this case, Dr. Anwer's opinion comes on the form of a checkbox. It's marginally useful and, as I indicated, ambiguous, at least with regard to sitting, standing, and walking.
I note that plaintiff -- the administrative
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 law judge relied on activities of daily living. In this, plaintiff -- as defense counsel noted, in his prior decision, ALJ Fein also relied on the same activities of daily living and, despite that, in the second hearing, at which plaintiff was represented, she did not adduce any additional evidence regarding her activities of daily living and the fact that they undermine Dr. Anwer's opinions.
Under Estrella Berryhill 925 F.3d 90 from 2019, Second Circuit, the Court must make a searching record of -- a searching review of the record and determine, considering the record as a whole, whether the treating source rule was violated. In this case I find that it was not.
The administrative law judge marshaled the evidence concerning plaintiff's physical condition, including at pages 28 and 29. The residual functional capacity finding was supported by other medical evidence in the record, including the opinion of consultative examiner Dr. Kalyani Ganesh, who, after examining the plaintiff, issued an opinion on July 31st, 2013, finding that plaintiff did not have any gross physical limitation noted; sitting, standing, walking, use of upper extremities; that appears at page 637 of the administrative transcript.
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 The RFC finding is also supported by the findings of non-examining counsel consultative expert Dr. Leong, including 23-F and 24-F of the administrative transcript.
One limitation of course, as Dr. Ganesh noted, was an environmental limitation which the administrative law judge properly rejected based upon plaintiff's heavy use of marijuana.
I note that the plaintiff does cite a case that she believes supports her position, Nelson versus Bowen, 882 F.3d 45 from the Second Circuit 1989. It's an old case, and it significantly predated the Poupore and other opinions which made clear that the burden was on the plaintiff and not the commissioner to prove residual functional capacity, it is also distinguishable.
The plaintiff quarrels with consideration of activities of daily living. Clearly, the reported activities of daily living are properly considered, Alpeter versus Commissioner of Social Security, 27 Westlaw 4443978 from Chief Judge Glenn T. Suddaby. Obviously there needs to be some consideration of the relation between the administrative -- the activities of daily living and the function in question.
But the bottom line is I'm unable to state
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 that a reasonable fact finder would have to credit the medical source statement of Dr. Anwer, and so I find, based on the totality of the evidence, including but not limited to the opinions of Dr. Ganesh and Dr. Leong, that the physical aspects of the residual functional capacity finding are supported.
Turning to the mental condition, the plaintiff, the focus would as --
(Technical issues) THE COURT: The focus is on the opinion of Nurse Practitioner Ann Sweet, that it --
(Technical issues) (Discussion held off the record) THE COURT: Addressing the mental residual functional capacity, plaintiff's challenge focuses on an opinion issued by Nurse Practitioner Ann Sweet and cosigned by Dr. Katherine Walia, dated July 7th, 2016, is Exhibit 9-F and appears at 696 to 698 of the administrative transcript.
It is a checkbox form. It lists symptoms of the plaintiff. It then asks to opine concerning plaintiff's abilities in several areas, A through U. The opinion indicates that plaintiff is unable to meet competitive standards in 11 categories. The opinion is discussed by Administrative Law Judge Fein at pages 30
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225 and 31 of the administrative transcript and given no weight.
I note initially that is unclear what Dr. Walia's role is. There is not any indication that she has treated the plaintiff and, therefore, does not qualify as a treating source. Nurse Practitioner Sweet, of course, under the former regulations, is not an acceptable medical source. The reasons cited will note given no weight includes the inconsistency of plaintiff's activities of daily living, and the fact that it is based in many respects on subjective reports, including the report that plaintiff feels that her neuropathy is incapacitating, that appears at 697, a proper consideration under Gates versus Astrue, 338 Fed Appx. 46, Second Circuit 2019. The opinion is also equivocal and use of the term "possible" in several respects, and it is based, at least in part, on the interplay between plaintiff's physical symptoms and her mental condition.
I note that the issue of Dr. Walia's involvement was identified in the first hearing in this matter and decision, but there was no proof offered at the second hearing as to Dr. Walia's involvement.
The opinion is also inconsistent with the evidence in question. For example, Nurse Practitioner
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225
Sweet opines that plaintiff is unable to use public transportation. The plaintiff admitted to Dr. Caldwell, at page 631, that she is capable using of public transportation.
The opinion is also inconsistent with the opinions of Dr. Christina Caldwell, a psychiatrist who examined the plaintiff and issued an opinion on July 31, 2014, that is consistent with the residual functional capacity finding. In other words, the limitations set forth at 631 and 632 of Dr. Caldwell's opinion has been accommodated by the residual functional capacity.
Dr. Kamin, an agency expert, non-examining, issued an opinion on August 12th, 2014, that's Exhibit 3-A, that also supports the finding of the administrative law judge, found only moderate limitation in several areas and opined that -- issued a mental residual functional capacity assessment; however, that is not inconsistent with the residual functional capacity he found.
There is a stress limitation set forth in Dr. Caldwell's opinion, and that is addressed in the residual functional capacity finding -- there's a stress limitation found by Dr. Caldwell that is addressed in the residual functional capacity finding Tatelman versus Colvin, 296 F. Supp. 3d 608 from the Western District of
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225
New York, 2017.
In support of his mental RFC finding, the administrative law judge cited treatment records and the opinions of Dr. Caldwell. The rejection of Nurse Sweet's opinion is supported by substantial evidence and a finding that the mental health component of the RFC is also supported by substantial evidence.
Turning to step five, I conclude with the exception that I mentioned at the outset, that the residual functional capacity finding was presented to the vocational expert, and the step five determination at which the commissioner bears the burden of proof was supported by substantial evidence based on vocational experts testimony.
So, in conclusion, I will grant judgment on the pleadings to the defendant and order dismissal of plaintiff's complaint.
Thank you all for excellent presentation. I'm sorry that we had to deal with the conditions of the telephone service. I wish you all well and stay safe.
(Proceeding concluded)
* * * * * * * * * * * Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY
COSBY v COMM. OF SOCIAL SECURITY - 20-cv-225
C E R T I F I C A T I O N I, Lisa L. Tennyson, RMR, CSR, CRR, Federal
Official Realtime Court Reporter, in and for the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York, do hereby certify that pursuant to Section 753, Title 28, United States Code, that the foregoing is a true and correct excerpt of the transcript of the stenographically reported proceedings held in the above-entitled matter and that the transcript page format is in conformance with the regulations of the Judicial Conference of the United States.
/s/ Lisa L. Tennyson
Lisa L. Tennyson, RMR, RPR, FCRR
Lisa L. Tennyson, CSR, RMR, FCRR UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT - NDNY
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.