U.S. Bank National Association v. Triaxx Asset Management LLC
Trial Court Opinion
USDC SDNY
DOCUMENT
ELECTRONICALLY FILED UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DOC #:
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK DATE FILED: _7/16/2] U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION,
Plaintiff, 18-CV-4044 (BCM) ‘ast ORDER RE TRUSTEE'S LETTER- “agen MOTION TO COMPEL
TRIAXX ASSET MANAGEMENT LLC, et al.,
Defendants.
BARBARA MOSES, United States Magistrate Judge.
By letter-motion dated June 22, 2021 (Trustee Ltr.) (Dkt. No. 356), Plaintiff U.S. Bank National Association (U.S. Bank or the Trustee) seeks an order compelling discovery from defendants Triaxx Asset Management LLC (TAM) and Phoenix Real Estate Solutions Ltd. (Phoenix) (collectively the TAM Parties). The TAM Parties filed a responding letter, opposing the requested relief, on July 6, 2021 (TAM Ltr.) (Dkt. No. 360). No conference is required. The Trustee's motion will be granted in part and denied in part as follows: 1. Additional Custodians. The Trustee contends that the TAM Parties should collect and produce documents from three additional custodians: Dom Savino, an employee of Phoenix ABS and a partner at 1/0 Capital, who according to the Trustee has knowledge of what it calls, imprecisely, "TAM's purchase of ICP Asset Management (TAM's predecessor)," Trustee Ltr. at 2; Raja Visweswaren, a Phoenix Director and founder of certain Phoenix affiliates, who 1s listed as an "individual to be noticed" in the 2011 Phoenix Engagement Letters and therefore, according to U.S. Bank, "should have knowledge" of them, id.; and Raza Khan, who along with Garg 1s identified in those Engagement Letters as a "Key Man" whose departure could trigger the termination of the engagement. Id.1 All three names appear in the TAM Parties' privilege log, with Savino's appearing the most frequently. Id. The TAM Parties resist, noting that they have already searched the email accounts of five custodians, from which they produced nearly 12,000 documents, and arguing that the additional searches now requested would be disproportional to the stakes in this action because Savino "communicated almost exclusively with the other custodians" and "performed minimal work relating to the Triaxx CDOs"; Visweswaran had a "high-level administrative role" but was "never involved in Phoenix's work for the Triaxx CDOs"; and Khan, who "has not been an officer of Phoenix since 2013," performed "no work relating to the Triaxx CDOs." TAM Ltr. at 2.2 The TAM Parties conclude that they should not be required to review "many more thousands of documents that are unlikely to yield relevant information," id., but do not provide any additional detail about either the time or the cost of performing the additional searches. On balance, the Court concludes that the Trustee has made an adequate case for including Savino and Khan as custodians. However, it has not shown that Visweswaran is likely to have any significant substantive knowledge concerning the parties' claims and defenses.
Consequently, the TAM Parties must collect and produce documents from Savino and Khan, but not Visweswaran.
2. Personal Email Accounts. The Trustee notes that some of the TAM Parties' custodians, including Garg and Calamari, used their personal gmail.com or yahoo.com email addresses to conduct TAM or Phoenix business, and requests that this Court order the TAM Parties
3. Inconsistent Application of Search Terms. The Trustee complains that the TAM Parties did not search all of their custodians' business email accounts using all of the approximately search terms and strings requested by the Trustee or negotiated among the parties. For example, four of those custodians had onezerocapital.com accounts, associated with Phoenix affiliate 1/0 Capital, which were only searched for a single term: "Triaxx." Trustee Ltr. at 3, App. The TAM Parties respond that since 1/0 Capital is not a party to this action and is in a "completely different business" from TAM or Phoenix, "Triaxx" should be sufficient to capture any relevant emails
4. Computers and Cloud Servers. The Trustee asserts that TAM has not searched any shared drives, hard drives, or cloud servers. Trustee Ltr. at 4.4 TAM concedes this fact, explaining that it "does not have shared drives" and that its "sole active employee" during the relevant time period was Calamari, who performed all of his work "over email." TAM Ltr. at 4. Although Calamari did save documents to (and edit them in) the "Downloads" folder of his "work computer," TAM has apparently not searched that folder – or any other location in Calamari's work computer – because everything in it was either sent to him or sent by him over email, making "discovery from that folder . . . duplicative." Id. TAM does not address whether it has – or Calamari used, for business purposes – any cloud servers, cloud-based storage programs (like Dropbox) or collaborative software programs (like Google Docs).
For these reasons, the Trustee's letter-motion is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. The Clerk of Court is respectfully directed to close Dkt. No. 356.
Dated: New York, New York
July 16, 2021
SO ORDERED.
BARBARA MOSES sis
United States Magistrate Judge > Calamari was not the only TAM-affiliated individual with a triaxxholdco.com email account during that period. Garg also had such an account. The TAM Parties make no representations regarding Garg's work habits or where (besides his triaxxholdco.com email account) Garg's TAM documents might reside.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.