Adasa Inc. v. R-Pac International LLC

District Court, S.D. New York

Adasa Inc. v. R-Pac International LLC

Trial Court Opinion

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK eee ee een ee eee eee ee eee eee x ADASA INC,, : □ : CLAIM CONSTRUCTION Plaintiff, . ORDER ragAInSt- : 24 Civ. 6102 (AKH) R-PAC INTERNATIONAL LLC (f/k/a R-Pac : International Corp., and f/k/a RIC Merger Sub : LLC), : Defendant. wane eee ee eee nenenecenenennenee ALVIN K. HELLERSTEI, U.S.D.J.: Pursuant to Markman v. Westview Instr., Inc.,

517 U.S. 370

(1998), the Court has reviewed the parties’ respective positions, and held a hearing on April 24, 2025, regarding ambiguities in the claim language of

U.S. Patent No. 9,798,967

. After consideration of the proposed constructions submitted by the parties, the Court adopts the constructions set out in the column entitled “Court’s Rulings” of the attached chart.

Dated: April 2025 MbMAAEE POA New York, New York / ALVIN K, HELLERSTEIN i United States District Judge

"oR , Bo GooF oS Bes —o in a oO a &. & i 2B Ro EB. a n go OF oo Zam bE oe So Te PEL ZR 2) Ba et Be S A oO Se, aa □ Bm a5 a oe 8 Bw Bw too 5. B a8 8 eel Spas BY. 8 2&0 Je . . . SE Bl gS mg So 6, B = 3 5 Bp ee RG Beas ° 28) Ez) ee] e288 a. 5 a to 2 8 Caer es. “3 © . = hk B8cs8s § ~ ees) ows 3 a on 3.5 ov B68 Fh Be) 2s Fe ees SE Bs] "geSe se 3 ef BR) g 2 o mh Bees a < 8 nl Sg 3: Sul fo 2S ge UE FRosB 2) 8 Ss a mo a 8 wm OD 3 oo oF = Dp om 4 tel oe a & oP BB mee Ay me A of © po Qo Rs, Bos E- = □□ wo 3 eB =o + Qegg ons cf 3S A Pa : ct re toa & 1s Oe. oe = = 5 By 8 8 oe B Be 5 ee. so □□ a. A oe e 8 = mp @ gh Pf BE to. □ N OE) 35 26 & 28 eae oO 2 oO oO □□ a oO = □ 25 Z Bo 5’ g. Bas s6¢ ct 4 a g Bo 8 maa 8 So oa EB 5 o a 7h ~ £8 Ge 5 g Qo BS Boa 5 BD gd wm 19 a a. Be 8 Be & mh oO [oO > □ Oo Oo oD 2 a z. pe & Fy + oO P. a B. 8 eo oF o J Ht 5 a oD = Ses g BO cr o n & sf me eo 49 cen S eae Oo p @ 4 oe 9 o fo», ct QO om meng BOE oo Bs a ao ooo e 68 mt or ‘5 o “an fel <8 RHE) BR 2 a □ : a □□ 1B) 8 gees| 268 58 o 2 =. ves &

Bee 4

□ rt. os — oO = a oa “a, © a a OF 3 Oo a 2 pe oo a B2eg “EB =. mt + S35 oO o © ° 5 ° Moon & a8 = A Pog? a5 6 o BF, S&S o o 2 n Sere Bo eo a oO Sa > © g 5. SS mn co — eh oh os = g eS ess Se )SF) Beg ae a3 □ = . a . oO oe 3 — Eo | B& aon @ 2S o Bo B<e gOS □ eel 8 = □ 2o8 | Soe e3oR Be = 38 & B. ao 8 Shoe “noo ee “bt, BS . Song 8 □ 3) g2\e¢8 ee | 292 SS eR S □ 5 ] ee oo oe = 5" "Ss "ne. oe 286 Bo □□ 5 = Ao mB oO Ne . m ob □□ a = 8 a "eB Ba “2 9 + ae Qa 0 me Bo SS 3 o Bog Sf 2a 28 o a od + 2g P a0.8 7 =. @ ch 2 oF ° □ ae gx Bi 8 So mf 8 □□ Bo » 2, a 8 g A to De 2 oa & 2. 5

Es Sears cE og ESE ei &. G8 oe OE. ae Se wk orgs 25 ko 38 we □ □□ Se eS o oO S3 6% . § Ue 5.8 be as St + a ag ae #8 26 Re □ of □ ag By Wa Od O a 9 to os Se Se 28 NS ‘4 aa □ □ Be Se □ ot Grp fe ao g& ee gg o> ao : $2 28 o □ Be = &% © □

noe ao ag @

BO a Bg PESREaESEAS 88 PESERESRS Ee 8 SGRSRQRAE □ w Po Bs BEBEE EES BS ee Behe Bo’ MH 5 g S thea o9g = 8s PSERZ= 8 8 Gg ee HE Saeeaugaebas By sag oe EEE gS ~ © gq gh □□ Ge: o fam ® i = Re =O th ae828 8 oO 2. 6 & oe 5 8 6 □□ □ > PSoFteQoeRee & 2s E2SE RSS 5 eS B22 528 & a 8 > □ eS see, B@2R8 2 Se fo Bo oS □□ B oss PEB GY Beas BBS Reso 2 iaecs 25 eaRreos “ o8 o Gao° oF & 7a □□

Lo

g gs ok a a 2S 3 BO □ mn OU SS, 6S Be □ Ti o Pr fH £2 oO me = oh □ be □□ #8 : Pp ~ eH 5? hm □ 2 □ fh wy a ae 1 b&b 29 % □□ a. ant ie oN Eg = a

Reference

Status
Unknown