nnn nnn nnn nnn □□ 1 USBC SPNY —

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT i OC “ SONICAL LY □□□ SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK 6 a □ No. 22-cv-627 (PAC) MATE Neb: □□□ 0c UPSOLVE, INC., and REV, JOHN UDO-OKON,

LETITIA JAMES, in her official capacity as 7 □ Attorney General of the State of New York, Ty □□ Defendant we ES ERWIN ROSENBERG'S SECOND MOTION FOR PERMISSIVE INTERVENTION

This Court is in a prelinunary stage as it has entered a preliminary injunction which is on appeal.

"Resolution of a motion for permissive intervention is committed to the discretion of the court before which intervention is sought. see Automobile Workers. 382 U.S. at 217, n, 10, 86 §.Ct. 373: Fed. Rule Civ. Proc, 24(b)\(1)(a)." Cameron v. EMW Women's Surgical Center, PSC, 142 8, Ct. 1002. 1011-1012 (2023),

Rosenberg would like to intervene to make a claim that Defenddant is violating federal antitrust law via its UPL laws and their enforcement. See Proposed Intervenor Complaint. The Plaintiffs and Rosenberg have a simular legal problem with Defendant and can obtain relief with the same essential antitrust argument in the praposed complaint.

keOwat 1.60f GY Vee LA Ree Lie it wre Cel teriwi ow edt wa UI

15. Paragraphs 1-10 and 13-13 are re-alleged. 16. Rosenberg's suffering of anti-trust damage is onging. 17. | Wherefore Rosenberg sues Defendant pursuant to

for

_ injunctive relief against threatened loss or damage by a violation of the antitrust laws.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Thereby certify I served upon filing this document which document was placed in a mailbox to S00 Pearl St, New York, NY 10007 on December 5, 2023.

Res ty Submitted,

VLE BW Ue bcs 1000 West Island Blvd. 1011 Aventura, Florida 33160 Tel 786-299-2789 . [email protected]

SO mn je LEWIS A. KAPLAN, USD] c .