New York Court of General Session of the Peace, 1958

People v. Recko

People v. Recko
New York Court of General Session of the Peace · Decided October 29, 1958 · Dickens
14 Misc. 2d 542; 179 N.Y.S.2d 126; 1958 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 2454

Counsel

Frank 8. Hogan, District Attorney (Harry Aid of counsel), for plaintiff., Chester Recko, defendant in person.

People v. Recko

Opinion of the Court

Thomas Dickens, J.

This coram nobis motion brought to vacate and nullify the judgment of conviction for a second felony offense based upon a prior felony conviction in a sister State, is denied.'

This court is without power to pass upon the legality or the validity of a prior foreign judgment of conviction although involved may be a claim, as in the instant case, of the failure of a court of a sister State to inform and advise a defendant of his constitutional right to be represented by counsel.

Defendant’s remedy, therefore, lies in the tribunal of original jurisdiction, that is, in the tribunal of the sister State. (See People v. McCullough, 300 N. Y. 107; People v. Sidoti, 1 A D 2d 232. See, also, discussion in Eli Frank, Coram Nobis [Cum. Supp.], p. 30, n. 32, 2d par. et seq.)

The District Attorney is directed to enter an order in conformance with the decision herein and to forward a certified copy to defendant.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.