The Superior Court of New York City, 1856

Powell v. Finch

Powell v. Finch
The Superior Court of New York City · Decided May 15, 1856 · Bosworth
5 Duer 666

Counsel

E. S. Vanwinkle and H. S. Cowdrey, for plaintiff., D. E. Wheeler, for defendants.

Powell v. Finch

Opinion of the Court

Bosworth, J.,

on a subsequent day, held, that the action is not in a condition to be tried. The defendant, who has not appeared, or been served, is not before the court.

A judgment that he execute such a bond and mortgage as the contract calls for cannot, rightfully, be rendered, nor enforced, as against him, if rendered.

A complete determination of the controversy cannot be had, without the presence of the third defendant. Service of a summons upon him, or his appearance in the action is indispensable. (Code, § 122.)

The trial which has been had must be treated as a nullity. The defendant, who has not been, must be served with process. When the action is in a condition, as against all the defendants, to be tried, it must be regularly noticed for trial, and be tried, as if no attempt to try it had been made.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.