The Superior Court of New York City, 1879

Muldoon v. Blackwell

Muldoon v. Blackwell
The Superior Court of New York City · Decided December 1, 1879 · Curtis
13 Jones & S. 635

Counsel

W. T. Birdsall, for appellants., J. A. Shoudy, for respondents.

Muldoon v. Blackwell

Opinion of the Court

Curtis, Ch. J.

The action is for goods sold and work and labor done. The answer sets up failure to perform, and matters by way of recoupment. Upon the close of plaintiffs’ case, it was submitted to the *636referee, who found for the plaintiffs. The evidence appears to sustain the findings of fact presented in the report of the referee. The exceptions of the defendants are not sufficient to call for a new trial.

The judgment appealed from should be affirmed with costs.

Freedman, J., concurred.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.