New York Supreme Court, 1807

Benson v. Matsdorf

Benson v. Matsdorf
New York Supreme Court · Decided August 15, 1807
2 Johns. 370

Counsel

Emott for the defendant., J. Tallmadge, contra.

Benson v. Matsdorf

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiamr

(stopping Tallmadge.) It is well settled,that the right to mesne profits is a uecessary consequence-' *371of a recovery in ejectment 5 and the defendant could not. set up a title in bar, even if he clearly had a better title; It cannot be said, that the second trial ascertained which had the better right. A court of law has no power to put an end to the litigation of.parties in.ejectment^ in this way. ■ _

Judgment for the plaintiff

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.