New York Supreme Court, 1841

Duffy v. People

Duffy v. People
New York Supreme Court · Decided May 15, 1841 · Cowen
1 Hill & Den. 355

Counsel

C. O'Connor, for plaintiff in error., A. L. Robertson, contra.

Duffy v. People

Opinion of the Court

By the Court, Cowen, J.

The constitution, in its language concerning trial by jury, and courts proceeding according to the course of the common law, (Art. 7, § 2,) evidently has reference to cases wherein an issue is joined, which may be followed by verdict' and judgment; not to that class of cases wherein the law. has interposed means of preventive justice. The statute of 1833, (ch. 11, § 7,) merely adds one to the class of disorderly persons, and authorizes a single magistrate to deal with him in a summary way, as all others of this class have long been dealt with; not to punish him for a crime committed, but require him *356tó give security that he will not commit a crime. This and the like, are not cases in which the trial by jury has ever been used.

Judgment affirmed.(a)

See Matter of Newell Smith, (10 Wend. 449.)

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.