New York Supreme Court, 1874

McRoberts v. Winant

McRoberts v. Winant
New York Supreme Court · Decided February 15, 1874 · Barnard
15 Abb. Pr. 210

Counsel

S. F. Dawson, showing cause for Winant, argued :, T. Westervelt, for McRoberts, argued:

McRoberts v. Winant

Opinion of the Court

J. F. Barnard, J.

Held that the statute must not be so construed as to defeat the will of the people as expressed at the election, and that the provision fixing the time for filing the bond might be held to be. directory. The bond having been approved by the supervisors, and filed in the clerks office, although after the time prescribed therefor, was a valid bond, and authorized McRoberts to take the office. That notwithstanding 1 Rev. Stat., p. 412, § 34, the defendant could not contest McRobert’s title, as he did not come within the statute authorizing officers to hold over.

Order for delivery of books, &c., granted.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.