New York Supreme Court, 1880

Badeau v. Niles

Badeau v. Niles
New York Supreme Court · Decided June 15, 1880 · Lawrence
9 Abb. N. Cas. 48

Counsel

Marston Niles, for defendant, Nathaniel Niles, and the motion., Washington JR. Nichols, for plaintiff, opposed.

Badeau v. Niles

Opinion of the Court

Lawrence, J.

The motion to strike out the portions of the complaint specified in the notice of motion should, I think, be granted. The allegations objected to relate rather to the evidence by which a cause of action may be established upon the trial, than to a statement of the facts constituting a cause of action. Even under the Code I do not understand that it is proper to plead the evidence by which a cause of action is to be established. In other words, the resultant, not the evidentiary, facts should be pleaded. $10 costs to defendant to abide event.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.