New York Supreme Court, 1907

O'Brien v. New York Butchers' Dressed Meat Co.

O'Brien v. New York Butchers' Dressed Meat Co.
New York Supreme Court · Decided May 15, 1907 · MacLean
54 Misc. 297; 105 N.Y.S. 950

Counsel

Phillips & Samuels, for plaintiff., Isaac Fromme, for New York Butchers’ Dressed Meat Company., Creevey & Rogers, for The Vilter Mfg. Company., No appearance for defendant Madden.

O'Brien v. New York Butchers' Dressed Meat Co.

Opinion of the Court

MacLean, J.

It having been held by the court of last resort “ that an action to foreclose a mechanic’s lien is a suit in equity ” (152 N. Y. 590), this court may not direct the trial by a referee of the issues herein which will require the examination of a long' account, and will not require the decision of difficult questions of law, for as announced in Prince Line, Lim. v. Seager (Mss.), “it is the rule in equitable actions that a trial of the main issue should first be had before the court.” But see 141 N. Y. 485, 488.

Ordered accordingly.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.