Sill v. Village of Corning
Sill v. Village of Corning
Dissenting Opinion
The design of the legislature to create a court of justice for the village of Corning, with limited civil jurisdiction, is plain enough. The main question involved is one of legislative authority. That alone I propose to examine.
An examination of the sixth article will show that it was designed to furnish a complete and perfect judicial system suitable to the public exigencies at the time, with som 1 qualities of adaptation to the increase of the business and population of the state in the future. For the state ai-t large, it provided a court of appellate jurisdiction in place the Court for the Correction of Errors, and a Supremo Court with general jurisdiction in law and equity. For the counties, it provided county courts and courts of sessions with limited civil and criminal jurisdiction, and for the several towns, it recognized and retained the justices of the peace, with such inferior local jurisdiction as the legislature might confer upon them. At common law a justice of the peace had no civil jurisdiction and no judicial power. “ His commission empowers him singly to conserve the peace; and therefore, gives him all the power of the ancient conservators, at common law, in suppressing riots and affrays, in taking securities for the peace, and in apprehending and committing felons and other inferior criminals.” (1 Bl. Com., 354.) The authority of the legislature to confer civil jurisdiction upon this class of magistrates is not given in express words; hut it is to be implied from their, possessing this jurisdiction at the time the constitution of 1846 was formed, and from the language of the fourteenth, seventeenth and twentieth sections of the sixth article, and from that of section ten of the fourteenth article. The design of a complete adaptation to the exigencies of the state at the time.
Any’ part of a town or towns, not included within any incorporated, village, and containing a resident population of not less than three hundred persons, may become incorporated as a village under the act of the 7th of December, 1847. If the authority which the legislature has exercised in respect to' the village of Corning really exists, all these small communities may become the seats of inferior courts of civil and criminal’ jurisdiction. The only color for the existence of this power is to be found in the eighteenth section of the sixth article, where it is said that “ all judicial officers of cities and villages, and all such judicial officers as may be created therein by law, shall be elected at such times and in such manner as the legislature shall direct.” The presence of the word villages, in this section, certainly does imply that there are judicial officers in villages, and that such officers may be created therein by law. Standing alone, however, in a section which relates exclusively to the election of certain officers, and not to the the erection of courts of justice, and unaided and unsupported, by any other words to be found in the instrument, it cannot be allowed the effect claimed for it. The express grant of the power, in respect to cities, must be construed into a prohibition of the same power in respect to villages.
It was said by the learned justice who decided the case at the special term, that “ a police justice of a city or village is nothing more nor less than a justice of the peace, restricted as to his powers and local jurisdiction.” I respectfully submit that there can be no such officer, out of the incorporated cities, as a justice of the peace restricted
The judgment and proceedings in the court below should be reversed.
Comstock and Selden, Js., concurred in this opinion.
Judgment affirmed.
Opinion of the Court
The village of Corning was incorporated pursuant to the provisions of the general act “ to provide for the incorporation of villages.” (Laws 1847, ch. 426.) The charter was twice amended. (Laws 1851, 612; Laws 1852, 48.) The questions presented by the case are, First. Whether the trustees had authority to pass the by-law for the violation of which the defendant was prosecuted ; and Secondly. Whether the magistrate had jurisdiction of the prosecution.
The general law for the incorporation, of villages, authorizes the trustees, of the corporations which maybe organised, to make by-laws to carry into effect the provisions of the act, “ and of other laws- applicable to such village,” “ and to prescribe penalties not exceeding twenty-five dollars for any violation of any such by-law;” but it is added that “ no such by-law shall prescribe any penalty for any act that shall be prohibited and for doing which a penalty shall be prescribed by the laws of the state.” (§57, subd. 25 ) The general power seems sufficient; but an objection is
It is argued that the legislature had no constitutional power to provide for the appointment of a police justice in a village, with jurisdiction to try and determine civil actions In support of this position it is maintained that the sixth article of the constitution makes express provision for all the courts of justice which it permits to be established in the state. The fact that a series of courts, from the court of impeachments down to the courts of justices of the peace, are required to be organized, by a necessary implication, as it is argued, excludes the power to create other courts, except in the single instance of city courts, provided for in section fourteen of that article. By that provision it is declared that “ Inferior local courts of civil and criminal jurisdiction, may be established by the legislature in cities; and such courts, except in the cities of New-York and Buffalo, shall have a uniform organization in such cities.” And this provision, according to the argument I am considering, greatly strengthens the implication, that except in cities no new courts can be created by the legislature. I am of the opinion that the provision respecting the higher courts, whose jurisdiction pervades the whole state, is exclusive in its character, and that no other courts of the same jurisdiction can be added by the legislature.
The remaining question is whether jurisdiction has really been conferred upon the magistrate to try the defendant on the complaint which was preferred against him ; and this is the most difficult point in the case. We must lay aside what is said, respecting a police justice, in the amendment of 1851. Those provisions were a plain violation of the constitution, for they authorized the trustees to appoint the justice; while the section of the constitution just referred to positively requires that all such officers in cities and villages should be “ elected, in such times and in such manner as the legislature shall direct.” The mode of appointment provided for being illegal, all the provisions conferring jurisdiction were equally void. The amendment of 1852 declared that a police justice should be elected in the village of Corning, but it did not, by reference or otherwise, adopt the provisions of the act of 1851, respecting the jurisdiction of the magistrate contained in that act. Though these provisions were in themselves nugatory, on account of the unconstitutionality of the mode of appointment of the officer, whose jurisdiction they attempted to define, it would have been competent for the legislature, when it provided a mode of appointment not forbidden by the constitution, to have transferred these provisions respecting jurisdiction to the new officer. But such is not the effect of the language made use of. The enactments of the former year respecting the police justice are not noticed, probably on account of their unconstitutionality; and the legislature begin anew with the declaration that “ there shall be elected in the village of Corning a police justice,” &c. (§1.) We must therefore look to the act of 1852, alone, for the powers of the officer. The name of police justice would not of itself suggest the idea of authority to try a civil action to recover a penalty, as
Johnson, Paige, Shankland and Bowen, Js., concurred in this opinion.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Sill against The Village of Corning
- Status
- Published