Morange v. Morris
Cases that cite this one
22 later published cases cite this decision.
- Offner v. Engelen (New York Supreme Court 1951)
- Campbell v. Prague (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1896)
- Zorn v. McParland (The Superior Court of New York City 1894)
- Rinaldo v. Hausmann (New York Court of Common Pleas 1876)
- Johnson v. Malone (Ala. 1949)
- Mahaney v. 580 Madison Ave., Inc. (New York Supreme Court 1930)
- Herman v. Ebert (N.J. 1923)
- Roberts v. New York Life Insurance (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1921)
- Pfister v. Heins (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1910)
- Alpern v. Farrell (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1909)
- Mandel v. Hess (New York Supreme Court 1907)
- Daly v. Bruen (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1903)
- Titcomb v. Fonda, Johnstown & Gloversville Railroad (New York Supreme Court 1902)
- Ewing v. . Wightman (N.Y. 1901)
- Miner v. Hilton (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1897)
- Ziehen v. . Smith (N.Y. 1896)
- Zorn v. McFarland (Superior Court of New York 1894)
- Ziehen v. Smith (New York County Courts 1893)
- Wilber v. Leonard (New York Supreme Court 1890)
- Bigler v. . Morgan (N.Y. 1879)
- Wood v. Squires (New York Supreme Court 1874)
- Hartley v. . James (N.Y. 1872)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
By the terms of the agreement the plaintiff was to pay the sum of $13,500 in cash, and by assuming the mortgages mentioned in the agreement, and to execute his bond and mortgage for the remaining $7,500 on the 21st September, 1857; and the defendant, on receiving such payments and the bond and mortgage at that time, was to convey to the plaintiff the lots in fee free from all incumbrances except said mortgages and the lease. These several acts were to be performed at the same time, and the obligations of the parties in respect to them, were, therefore, mutual and dependent. (Gardiner agt. Carson, 15 Mass. 500; Grant agt. Johnson 1 Seld. 247; Holmes agt. Holmes 5 Seld. 525 ; Beecher agt. Comrade, 3 Kern. 108.)
Ordinarily it is incumbent on each party to an agreement creating mutual and dependent obligations to perform or tender a performance on his part, in order to put the other party in default. There may be circumstances, however, which will excuse a party from such performance, and enable him to take advantage of the default of the other party.
In the present case the vendor was unable to perform his agreement, for the reason that the premises were incumbered with the liens for taxes and assessments, .admitted in the answer. By his agreement, he was not only to convey a title in fee simple, but he was to convey and assure it free from all incumbrances- except as therein specified, and the incumbrances referred to were not within the exceptions. The existence of the incumbrances at the time fixed in the agreement for the execution and delivery of a deed, was a breach of the agreement on his part, which put it out of his power to perform, and excuse the plaintiff from tendering payment. (See Holmes agt. Holmes, 12 Barb 137 • S. C. Aff. 5 Seld. 525.)
The averment in the answer, that the defendant would have discharged the incumbrances on the 21st of September, if the plaintiff had been ready and willing to perform on his part, is wholly immaterial. The act of conveying the premises free from all incumbrances, was to be concurrent with that of the payment of the purchase money.
The plaintiff was under no obligation to pay his money to the vendor and trust to a remedy by action for damages, in case the vendor failed to remove the incumbrances. It was the duty of the defendant to have caused them to be discharged before the time arrived at which he had stipulated to convey.
Equally immaterial is the averment that the defendant would have discharged the incumbrances on the 21st of Sep
I think the judgment should be affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.