Fillo v. Jones
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Van Orden v. Andrews (New York Supreme Court 1887)
- Quinlan v. City of Utica (New York Supreme Court 1877)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
It is not claimed on the part of the plaintiff, that the keeping and storing of the fire-works in contravention of the city ordinance, was, for that reason alone, such an unlawful act as to bring the case within the statute authorizing a recovery, and upon the authority of Brown v. The Buffalo & State Line R. R. Co. (22 N. Y. 191), it seems that position would have been untenable. It became necessary, therefore, for the plaintiff to show, either that the defendant was guilty of negligence in the mode of keeping and storing, or handling those articles, or that such keeping and storing was of itself an unlawful act, .at common law, because a common nuisance, dangerous to human life. There was no evidence tending to show the former state of facts. So far as appears, these fire-works were put up, kept and handled by the defendant, in the ordinary manner, and with proper care and precaution against accidents. The theory of the plaintiff’s case is, that the defendant was guilty of a wrongful and unlawful act, or of default, in keeping them at all at the place where they were kept, because they were, in themselves, liable to spontaneous combustion and explosion, and thus endangered the lives of persons in their vicinity, and that the injury here complained of was occasioned by such. spontaneous combustion or explosion of a portion of their
The objection to this evidence of the witness Parker, was therefore radical, and such as could not have been obviated had it been stated with ever so much particularity. Such being the case, I regard the objection as sufficient, and the ruling upon it as. erroneous.
The same remarks apply to the ruling upon the defendant’s objection to the evidence of the witness Patrick Holloway. That witness was allowed to testify to the occurrence and cause of a fire in the store of Duncan & Eobbins, where he was employed as a porter, in 1855. In that casé the defendant’s objection was more specific. He objected “ to all testimony as to other fires.”. The objection was overruled, and the defendant excepted-. The witness then went on to state the circumstances of this fire, to give his opinion that it was occasioned by spontaneous combustion, and to testify that it was also accompanied by loss of life. The effect of the evidence of both of these witnesses upon the jury, cannot be doubted; aside from its bearings upon the question at issue, as to which it was incompetent, it was calculated to create a feeling of hostility to the business m which the defendant was engaged, and thus to work to his prejudice.
A witness, Henry Whitaker, Jr., testified that, in May, 1867, he purchased of Mr. Edge, pyrotechnist, of Jersey City, four colored signal lights, two red and two green, and the next day delivered them to Professor Doremus, a chemist of Hew York city. Thereupon Professor Doremus was called,
There was another ruling upon an objection to evidence, which it seems to me impossible to sustain. Alfred E. Baker, fire marshal of the city of Hew York, was called as a witness for the plaintiff, and testified that two or three months previous to the fire, he received an anonymous letter from some person unknown, relating to the defendant’s business, and having sworn to the loss of the document, he was asked to state its contents. The defendant’s objection to such evidence was overruled, and the witness stated, in substance, the contents of the letter, viz., that it directed the attention of the fire marshal to the' establishment of the defendant, as containing a large quantity of dangerous fire-works, subjecting the neighborhood to great peril in case of an explosion. The defendant’s objection to this evidence, as in one or two former instances, was general. But I am of opinion that it was sufficient. The reason of the rule requiring the grounds
For these errors in the ruling of the court, upon objection to evidence, I am clearly of opinion that the judgment at the Circuit was erroneous, and that the defendant was entitled to a new trial. The judgment of the General Term must therefore be affirmed, and, under the plaintiff’s stipulation, judgment absolute must be awarded to the defendant.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.