Youngs v. . Kent
Cases that cite this one
23 later published cases cite this decision.
- Mann v. Luke (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1947)
- Riverside Chemical Co. v. City of Niagara Falls (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1945)
- Sanchez v. Spitzka (New York Supreme Court 1944)
- Hespe v. Corning Glass Works, Inc. (District Court, W.D. New York 1935)
- Voris v. Schmaling (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1918)
- Sharp v. Sharp (New York Supreme Court 1914)
- Neubauer v. American Seating Co. (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western New York 1909)
- Rochkind v. Perlman (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1908)
- Rochkind v. Perlman (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1908)
- Rankin v. Bush (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1904)
- Manne v. Carlson (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1900)
- Manne v. Carlson (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1900)
- Andreae v. Bandler (New York Supreme Court 1899)
- Barton v. Griffin (New York Supreme Court 1898)
- Lloyd v. Ballantine (New York Supreme Court 1897)
- Metzger v. Metropolitan Elevated Railway Co. (New York Supreme Court 1893)
- Newell Bros. Manufacturing Co. v. Grunwald (City of New York Municipal Court 1888)
- Burley v. German-American Bank (Supreme Court of the United States 1884)
- Cook v. . Warren (N.Y. 1882)
- Houser v. C., R. I. & P. R. (Iowa 1882)
- Clark v. Dillon (New York Court of Common Pleas 1882)
- Hull, Lanier & Co. v. Carter (N.C. 1880)
- Chatham National Bank v. Shipman (New York Supreme Court 1880)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Without passing upon the merits of the answer, so far as it attempts an affirmative defence, we are of the opinion that material allegations of the complaint were put in issue by other parts of the answer. The allegations in the complaint of the quantity delivered of the sugar in the aggregate, were material, and if controverted presented an issue of fact fof trial. It is true the denial of those allegations are not as artistic and formal as they might, and, perhaps, should have been, but they are not among the allegations expressly admitted, and they are not alluded to in the statement of special facts alleged in the answer, and, therefore, may be regarded as controverted under the denial of each and every allegation of the complaint except as “herein admitted or stated.”
It is possible that the pleader had it not in his mind in preparing the answer to make a point upon the quantity and value of the property, but to contest only the cause of action. But the allegations of the complaint and the denial of the answer are upon the record, and the court cannot, by a. summary judgment, deprive the defendants of the right- of- a trial of the issue thus formed. The question presented was neither frivolous nor immaterial. The form and structure of the answer woidd indicate, that the right of the plaintiffs to recover at all was the question intended to be made-. But by the forms of pleading the other question is, infact, presented, and cannot be disregarded.
This conclusion obviates the necessity of determining any question as to the sufficiency of" the • defence-attempted by the statements of the answer aside from the denial-..
An answer may be bad upon demurrer and so. held, and yet not be frivolous so as to authorize a summary judgment. An answer merely defective in form or substance,.may be amended *674 by leave of the court, either upon demand or upon the trial of the issues, but a frivolous ¡answer is evidence of bad faith, 'and is not ordinarily amendable.
The fact that an answer is insufficient in form of substance, does not necessarily determine that it is frivolous. That only may be regarded as frivolous, which is made to appear so inControvertibly by a bare statement of it ’and without argument. If an argument is required to show that the pleading is bad, it is not frivolous. But without considering the sufficiency of the answer, or whether it is or is not frivolous, or the legal questions presented by it; for the reason that there was a material issue of 'fact presented by the pleadings which should have been tried, the ¡judgment is reversed, and the action remitted to the court below for further proceedings, costs to abide the event.
-All concur.
•Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.