Anonymous
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- Privitera v. Town of Phelps (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1981)
- Kotkin v. Kerner (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1968)
- 600 West 115th Street Corp. v. Von Gutfeld (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1991)
- Wagner v. Wagner (New York Supreme Court 1966)
- Luna De La Peunte v. Seattle Times Co. (Wash. 1936)
- Amick v. Montross (Iowa 1928)
- Reinboth v. Ederheimer (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 1912)
- Lynott v. Pearson (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1910)
- Cady v. Brooklyn Union Publishing Co. (New York Supreme Court 1898)
- Nealon v. Frisbie (Superior Court of New York 1895)
- Nealon v. Frisbie (The Superior Court of New York City 1895)
- Hemmens v. . Nelson (N.Y. 1893)
- Hessel v. Johnson (Pa. 1889)
- Pegram v. Stortz (W. Va. 1888)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The words charged are not actionable per se. To make them such it is not enough that the charge thereby imputed was one involving turpitude in a moral sense, but it must constitute an indictable offence, upon conviction of which punishment may be inflicted. (Young v. Miller, 3 Hill, 21; Crawford v.Wilson, 4 Barb., 504.) The charge in the present case, if true, would not subject the plaintiff to an indictment for any criminal offence. In this I exclude any idea that an indecent public exposure of the person was included in the charge made by the defendant. There was no evidence tending to show this.
The only question is, whether the special damage alleged and proved was sufficient to maintain the action. The case shows that the plaintiff was a minor, about eighteen years old, residing with her father, by whom she was provided for and maintained; that prior to his having heard of the charge made against the plaintiff by the defendant, he had promised to give her a course of music lessons upon a piano and a silk dress, both of which he refused to do after hearing that the defendant had made the charge, until it was cleared up. He testified that he wholly disbelieved in its truth. Damage, to sustain the action, must be the natural and immediate consequence of speaking the words. (Terwilliger v. Wands,
I have reluctantly come to the conclusion, in the present case, that the damage alleged and proved was not such as to maintain the action, for the reason that the charge preferred was against a young female, and of a nature greatly to distress her and very much annoy her friends, and one made up by the defendant, without any foundation whatever in truth, as I think any one must be satisfied, from the testimony of the witness to whom the defendant first told the story. The defendant deserves punishment, but the action of slander will not afford a remedy.
The judgment appealed from must be affirmed.
All concur; MILLER, J., not sitting.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.