Audenreid v. Mercantile Mutual Insurance
Audenreid v. Mercantile Mutual Insurance
Opinion of the Court
The policy was upon the steamboat Meteor, her tackle, etc., at and from Philadelphia to Hew York, with liberty to touch and stay at any ports and places, if thereunto obliged by stress of weather or other unavoidable accident. The perils insured against were those of the sea and such as are covered by marine policies, including fires.
The vessel was destroyed by fire, after the commencement of the voyage, and while laying at the wharf at Chester, on the Delaware river, an interjacent port between Philadelphia and Hew York. The voyage was interrupted for the repair, at the place of the loss, of a defect or crack in -the steam chimney, which existed and was known to the owners of the vessel before the departure from Philadelphia. The repairs were not made necessary by any thing that occurred after the commencement of the voyage, or by any of the perils insured against. Heither was the steamer “ obliged by stress of weather or other unavoidable accident,” to touch or stay at the port or place at which she was burned. The delay at that place was the voluntary act of those in charge of the vessel, and was not excused by any of the circumstances which are • recognized as justifying a deviation from the usual course of a voyage as between insurers and insured. If, therefore, the delay was a departure from the due and usual course of the voyage insured, it was a violation of the implied conditions of the policy, and the risk had terminated at the time of the loss. A deviation is a varying from the route insured against without necessity or just cause after the risk has begun, and the effect of a deviation is to discharge the underwriters whether the risk is thereby enhanced or not. It is not con
Permission to touch and stay at Chester for repairs or any other purpose was not given by the contract of insurance, and the risk was necessarily varied by such act. The vessel was exposed to perils while at the wharf, in charge of one or more of the hands and the chief officers absent, which she would not have encountered in the due prosecution of the voyage. The voyage was also prolonged, and the continuance of the risk in point of time increased, if the policy was valid, while the vessel should be detained at the intermediate port, and was to continue as provided in the policy until she safely arrived at Hew York and “ should be moored twenty-four hours in good safety.” It is self-evident that a risk upon a vessel at and from Philadelphia to Hew York direct and without delay, is
In the absence of any usage or stipulation to the contrary, the meaning of the parties to the policy is that the ship shall proceed from one terminus of the voyage insured, to the other, in a direct course, with all due expedition and without touching at any interjacent port, or pursuing any intermediate adventure. (1 Arnold on Ins., 354; Brown v. Tayleur, 4 A. & E., 241; Coffin v. Newburyport M. Ins. Co., 9 Mass., 436 ; Hobart v. Norton, 8 Pick., 159; Fernandez v. Great West. Ins. Co., 48 N. Y., 571.)
The question now under consideration, cannot arise upon time policies, as there can ordinarily be no deviation under policies of that character. Dixon v. Sadler (5 M. & W., 405), was upon such a policy. The cases involving the question of seaworthiness in different stages of a voyage, or those in which the effect of a license to touch and stay at intermediate ports are considered, some of which were cited by the learned counsel for the plaintiff, do not bear upon the case in hand, or elucidate any principle involved, and need not therefore be particularly referred to.
We are of the opinion that the policy was terminated by the interruption of the voyage and the delay at Chester with
The order granting a new trial should be affirmed and judgment absolute for the defendant, pursuant to stipulation. All concur.
Order affirmed and judgment accordingly.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- William G. Audenreid, etc. v. The Mercantile Mutual Insurance Company
- Status
- Published