Byrne v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad
Cases that cite this one
18 later published cases cite this decision.
- Felton v. Aubrey (6th Cir. 1896)
- Morrison v. Carpenter (Mich. 1914)
- Freeman v. Brooklyn Heights Railroad (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1900)
- Davey v. Southern Pacific Co. (Cal. 1896)
- Burk v. President of Delaware & H. Canal Co. (New York Supreme Court 1895)
- Schulman v. Houston, W. S. & P. F. Railroad (Superior Court of New York 1895)
- Vandewater v. New York & New England Railroad (New York Supreme Court 1893)
- Reardon v. Thompson (Mass. 1889)
- Query v. Postal Telegraph Cable Co. (N.C. 1919)
- Missouri, K. & T. R. Co. v. Wolf (Okla. 1919)
- Monroe v. Atlantic Coast Line Railroad (N.C. 1909)
- Knight v. Lanier (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1902)
- Clark v. Michigan Central Railroad (Mich. 1897)
- Schulman v. Houston, West Street & Pavonia Ferry Railroad (The Superior Court of New York City 1895)
- Davis v. New York, New Haven, & Hartford Railroad (Mass. 1893)
- Larkin v. New York & N. R. (New York Court of Common Pleas 1892)
- June v. Boston & Albany Railroad (Mass. 1891)
- Buck v. Manhattan Railway Co. (New York Court of Common Pleas 1888)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
There was some controversy upon the trial of this action as to whether or not the place where the plaintiff was injured was a traveled public highway, and the trial judge submitted the ease to the jury upon the assumption that it was not. There was, however, evidence tending to show that there was an alley, at the place where the plaintiff was injured, which was extensively and notoriously used by the public, without any objection on the part of the defendant, or any question as to the right of all persons so to use it;
There are points of resemblance and points of difference between the Barry Case and the other cases. Taking the points of resemblance, a plausible argument may be made to show that the cases conflict. But taking the points of difference, then, while the distinction between the Barry Gase and the other cases is not so plain as a traveled highway, it is sufficient to require the application of different principles and the reaching of a different result.
The facts of this case, so far as they relate to the accident, are substantially the same as those proved upon the trial which was under review in 83 N. Y. 620, when this ease first came to this court. Then we held that there was evidence sufficient for the consideration of the jury, both in reference to the plaintiff’s contributory negligence and the negligence on the part of the defendant, and we see no reason to reconsider the conclusion in reference to those matters then reached. It is quite true that the evidence to establish freedom from negligence on the part of the plaintiff, and negligence on the part
There was evidence tending to show that no bell was rung or whistle blown upon the engine attached to the train in approaching this crossing, and the court charged the jury that the defendant was not absolutely bound to ring a bell or to blow a whistle, but that it was bound to give such notice or warning of the approaching train as was reasonable and proper under the circumstances; that it was bound to give by bell, whistle or otherwise such reasonable notice as the jury should find the circumstances required. The charge as thus made was excepted to on the part of the defendant, and its counsel requested the court to charge that if the bell was rung, as testified to by defendant’s witnesses, that was a sufficient warning of the approach of the train, and that the defendant was not bound to give any other notice or warning. The judge refused so to charge and the defendant’s counsel excepted. In these ruling^,, there was no error. The defendant was backing its train toward this crossing which was extensively and notoriously used by the public, and it was bound to use reasonable and ordinary care so as not to endanger those who might be lawfully upon its track at that crossing. And what care and precautions, if any, besides ringing the bell it should have taken upon a train thus .backing were properly left for the jury to determine; and so it was held in the Barry Oase. There, as here, there was a dispute as to whether the bell was rung or the whistle blown as a warning for the approach of the train. There the court charged the jury that in running its cars the defendant was bound to give such notice and warning as in their judgment would be regarded as reasonable and proper and calculated fairly to protect the lives of persons using the crossing; that they were to determine whether in backing the train-it observed that care and caution which was called for under the circumstances ; and that it had a right to back the train, but, under the circumstances of the case, the question was whether it had the right to back it without giving
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.