Waite v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad
Opinion of the Court
This action was brought to recover damages for delay in the delivery of a boiler shipped to the plaintiffs from Boston. Their recovery, which was sustained by the general term, is resisted here, mainly upon two grounds.
It is claimed that the action was upon an express con
And when in answer to that motion the court held in defendant’s favor in respect to a contract but submitted the question of negligence to the jury the counsel for the railroad company excepted because no negligence had been proved and upon the whole evidence could not be said to exist. Upon these facts it is entirely clear that the defendant was in no respect surprised or misled and has no just reason to complain of the action of the court.
The next contention is that upon the facts the defendant was shown to have exercised reasonable care and was not chargeable with negligence. I think that was quite certainly a question for the jury. The way-bill of the property reached the agent of the Boston and Albany road at its terminus in East Albany on the eleventh of September, and on that day was sent by messenger to the agent of the defendant who thereafter forwarded it to the freight agent at Little Falls, who received it the next day.
That way-bill, dated September tenth, was “ of merchandise from Boston to Little Falls; ” specified the car as “ B. and A., 2390; ” named the plaintiffs as consignees; described the property as machinery; and fixed the amount of freight chargeable by each road. The property arrived on September thirteenth, and was by the Boston and Albany agents unloaded from car 2390, together with some other machinery consigned to East St. Louis, and transferred to defendant’s car numbered 20126. That car was taken across the bridge and to West Albany, and there taken out of the train and held for want of a conductor’s slip or other evidence of its destination. On the fourteenth or fifteenth of September, Ingraham, who represented the Boston and Albany, sent to J. J. Jones, the dispatch agent of the defendant, a notice which is in this form : “ 2390, B. and A.,, Boston to E. St. Louis, 10, transferred to 20126 N. Y. C.”
A further exception is argued, growing out of the refusal by the court to admit in evidence certain letters written by the agents of the Boston and Albany, in answer to letters from the agents of the defendant. This correspondence is among the exhibits attached to the case. The first letter of Ingraham was dated October seventeenth, and the second October twenty-seventh. Both were written long after the mistake had occurred; the first on the day the property finally reached Little Falls, and the second, ten days later; and both were the unsworn statements narrative of a past occurrence of the agents of the Boston and Albany road, which last was not a party to the action. They were not admissible, but if they had been, they would have been badly damaging to the defendant, for not only do they tend to fasten the charge of negligence upon the defendant, but do it so forcibly and with so much reason, that at the close of the correspondence their offer to bear a part of the loss seems at least liberal and fair.
Several objections were taken to the admission and rejec
The judgment should be affirmed with costs.
All concur.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.