Northam v. Dutchess County Mutual Insurance
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- Beer v. Clyde Steamship Co. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1925)
- American Mills Co. v. Hoffman (2d Cir. 1921)
- Friedrich v. Martin (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1943)
- Electric Equipment Corp. v. Delco Appliance Corp. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1937)
- Williamson v. Atlas Powder Co. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1925)
- Flinsch v. Viele, Blackwell & Buck (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1920)
- Whipple v. . Brown Brothers Co. (N.Y. 1919)
- Walrath v. . Hanover Fire Ins. Co. (N.Y. 1915)
- Lamphere v. . Lang (N.Y. 1915)
- Walrath v. Hanover Fire Insurance (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1912)
- Silvert v. Kommel (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1910)
- Abromovitz v. Markowitz (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 1908)
- Stone v. Stolts (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 1908)
- Epstein v. Cohen (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 1907)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The complaint was plainly upon the policy issued by the defendant and not for damages for the breach of a verbal contract between the parties. There was evidence to show that, in consideration of the plaintiff’s promise to pay the unpaid premium, the defendant agreed to insure the plaintiff’s interest in the property mentioned in the policy issued to his assignor, by a proper indorsement upon such policy if it could be obtained, or if not, by issuing a- slip or paper to him which “ would keep the • insurance all right and insure him from that time.” If the action had been based upon that contract, the proof was sufficient to have justified the jury in finding for the plaintiff. (Ellis v. Albany City F. Ins. Co., 50 N. Y. 402; Angell v. Hartford F. Ins. Co., 59 id. 171; Ruggles v. Am. Cent. Ins. Co., 114 id. 415 ; Manchester v. Guardian, Assur. Co., 151 id. 88; Squier v. Hanover F. Ins. Co., 162 id. 552; Hicks v. British Am. Assur. Co., 162 id. 284; Northam v. International Ins. Co., 45 App. Div. 177; affd. on opinion below, 165 N. Y. 666.)
But the action was based upon the policy alone, and it is obvious that the proof was insufficient to establish a valid transfer or continuance of the policy in accordance with its requirements and provisions.
This does not fall within the class of cases where, although' the complaint is insufficient, the proof is sufficient to authorize a recovery and. is admitted without objection, and where the pleadings may be amended to conform to the proof. In this case the plaintiff failed to prove the cause of action alleged, and the evidence tending to establish a different cause of *75 action was objected to upon the ground that it was inadmissible under the pleadings and no amendment was asked for. In such a case, if the plaintiff fails to prove the cause of action set up'in his complaint and proper objections are made upon the trial, and no amendment of the pleading is asked for or ordered, a judgment in the plaintiff’s favor upon a cause of action not alleged cannot be sustained on appeal, nor after trial can the pleadings be conformed to the proof. (South-wick v. First Nat. Bank of Memphis, 84 N. Y. 420; Trues-dell v. Sarles, 104 id. 164, 167; Pope v. Terre Haute Car and Mfg. Co., 107 id. 61; Freeman v. Grant, 132 id. 22, 28; Reed v. McConnell, 133 id. 425, 434; Bradt v. Frank, 164 id. 515, 519.)
Therefore, it is manifest that the learned trial court erred in admitting, under the defendant’s objection and exception, evidence of the verbal agreement between the parties, and also in submitting the case to the jury upon the theory that the plaintiff might recover if the jury should find that such an agreement Avas made.
The defendant’s exceptions to the admission of that evidence and to the charge of the court in that respect were well taken and require a reversal of the judgment.
The judgment should be reversed and new trial granted, with costs to abide the event.
Parker, Ch. J., Gray, O’Brien, Haight, Cullen and Werner, J J., concur.
Judgment reversed, etc.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.