In re the Estate of Rogers
Cases that cite this one
19 later published cases cite this decision.
- Majteles v. AVL Corp. (New York Supreme Court 1999)
- In re Myers (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1964)
- In re the Estate of Behm (New York Surrogate's Court 1962)
- In re the Estate of Barbey (New York Surrogate's Court 1962)
- Merrick Estates Civic Ass'n v. State Tax Commission (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1978)
- In re the Estate of Tricarico (New York Surrogate's Court 1972)
- In re the Estate of Horchler (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1971)
- In re the Estate of Cushing (New York Surrogate's Court 1966)
- In re the Estate of Meyer (New York Surrogate's Court 1966)
- In re the Estate of Caro (New York Surrogate's Court 1965)
- Rockefeller Center Luncheon Club, Inc. v. Schwartz (New York Supreme Court 1964)
- In re the Estate of Behm (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1963)
- In re the Estate of Singer (New York Surrogate's Court 1962)
- Marx v. Bragalini (N.Y. 1959)
- In re Savoy Ballroom Corp. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1955)
- In re the Estate of Harbord (New York Surrogate's Court 1951)
- In re the Estate of Rhodes (New York Surrogate's Court 1949)
- In re the Estate of Walk (New York Surrogate's Court 1948)
- In re the Estate of Ayer (New York Surrogate's Court 1948)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Dissenting Opinion
We are asked upon this appeal to overrule a long line of decisions by this court, in the interests of uniformity, because the Supreme Court of the United States has recently decided contrariwise. While the rule of uniformity is entitled to great weight and would ordinarily persuade us to follow the Supreme Court's construction of the Federal prototype of our estate tax law, we cannot see our way clear to do so here.
It has long been settled in this State that where the exercise of a general testamentary power of appointment transfers nomore to the beneficiary than he would have received — in default of such exercise — under the instrument creating the power, the property is deemed, for the purposes of death taxation, to have passed under the latter instrument by operation of law, and is, therefore, not taxable in the estate of the donee. (Matter ofVanderbilt,
In our opinion, no defect in reason or logic has been advanced which warrants our repudiation of the rule heretofore adopted by this court. Reversal of the order herein is accordingly indicated, unless we are compelled, in the interests of uniformity of estate tax administration, to abandon our own rules whenever they conflict with Federal decisions in such matters.
The "rule" or "doctrine" — if such it may be called — of uniformity grows out of the fact that the New York estate tax law (Tax Law, art. 10-C) was purposely modeled upon the Federal estate tax law to simplify the legal and administrative work involved (N.Y. Legis. Doc., 1930, No. 69, p. 195). Originating in the Surrogate's courts (see, e.g., Matter of French,
The rule has, up to the present, been applied only (1) in *Page 680 cases of first impression and (2) in cases where the question involved — though previously passed upon by this court in connection with prior tax laws — is being raised for the first time under the estate tax law. We do not believe that its application should be extended to cases where the precise point in issue has already been raised and passed upon under the existing estate tax law. More particularly, we do not believe that the court is either compelled to, or should, in the interests of uniformity, abandon a construction of the New York estate tax law — a construction not only in accord with our previously settled and well-considered opinion, but one previously approved and adopted by the Supreme Court itself and by it applied to the Federal estate tax law. (Helvering v.Grinnell, supra, pp. 156-157.) Under all of the circumstances, we choose to adhere to our settled rule.
The order of the Appellate Division should be reversed, with costs, and the order of the Surrogate's Court affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.