MATTER OF DAVIS v. Bd. of Elections
MATTER OF DAVIS v. Bd. of Elections
Opinion of the Court
On September 9, 1958 an independent nominating petition, nominating appellant Benjamin J. Davis for the office of State Senator, 21st Senatorial District, was filed in the office of the Board of Elections of the City of New York. There were 5,988 signatories to this nominating petition, and this group adopted the name of Peoples Bights Party. Subsequently, and as a result of written objections filed with it, the Board of Elections found that 3,580 of the signatories had not registered at the time of the last preceding general election. Additional signatures, not involved here, were found invalid for various other reasons. The invalidation of the afore-mentioned 3,580 signatures brought the total number of signatories below 3,000, the number required by law (Election Law, § 138, subd. 5, par. [c], cl. [4]); hence, the nominating petition was declared invalid.
Section 138 of the Election Law prescribes the requirements for independent nominating petitions, and subdivision 6 thereof provides, in part, as follows: “ The name of a person signing such a petition for an election for which voters are required to be registered shall not be counted if such person was not registered at the time of the last preceding general election as a qualified voter; * * V' Appellant's principal contention, arid the only one to which we deem it necessary to refer, is that this provision is arbitrary and violative of section 1 of article I of the Constitution of this State in that it disfranchises citizens who, though qualified to vote, did not register at the time of the last preceding general election.
Section 1 of article I of the New York Constitution declares that “No member of this state shall be disfranchised, or
Dissenting Opinion
In my view the discrimination in section 138 of the Election Law against voters coming of age, becoming naturalized or changing their residences to the voting area within the year previous to the election, creates an infirmity which invalidates the entire provision requiring registration to vote at the election of the previous year. If that requirement is void, as I think it is, this independent nominating petition is valid and the petitioner is a person aggrieved. The signers of the petition have not estopped themselves or the petitioner so as to compel compliance by them with this void requirement. The petition was not rejected on the ground that any of the signers are now minors, aliens, illiterates, etc. The order1 appealed from should be reversed and the petition granted.
Chief Judge Conway and Judges Desmond, Dye, Fuld, Froessel and Burke concur in Per Curiam opinion; Judge Van Voorhis dissents and votes to reverse in a separate memorandum.
Order affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- In the Matter of Benjamin J. Davis, Appellant, Against Board of Elections of the City of New York, Respondents
- Cited By
- 9 cases
- Status
- Published