People v. Cull
Cases that cite this one
77 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Downey v. Allstate Insurance (District Court, S.D. New York 1986)
- KENAI PEN. FISHERMAN'S CO-OP. ASS'N v. State (Alaska 1981)
- Kenai Peninsula Fisherman's Cooperative Ass'n v. State (Alaska 1981)
- Yaretsky v. Blum (District Court, S.D. New York 1978)
- Abdil v. Martinez (New York Supreme Court 2002)
- People v. Attco Metals Industries, Inc. (New York County Courts 1984)
- Hill v. New York State Teachers' Retirement System (New York Supreme Court 1978)
- People ex rel. Kinard v. New York State Division (New York Supreme Court 1997)
- Guptill Holding Corp. v. Williams (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1988)
- W. Va. Chiropractic Society, Inc. v. Merritt (W. Va. 1987)
- People v. Schapiro (New York County Courts 1986)
- People v. A-1 Roofing Service, Inc. (Appellate Division of the Superior Court of California 1978)
- Lang v. Berger (District Court, S.D. New York 1977)
- Percy v. Brennan (District Court, S.D. New York 1974)
- Plainview-Old Bethpage Congress of Teachers v. New York State Health Insurance Plan (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2016)
- Plainview-Old Bethpage Congress of Teachers v. New York State Health Insurance Plan (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2016)
- Cubas v. Martinez (N.Y. 2007)
- Alca Industries, Inc. v. Delaney (N.Y. 1999)
- Rubin v. New York State Education Department (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1994)
- Connell v. Regan (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1986)
- People v. Motley (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1986)
- Jones v. Smith (N.Y. 1985)
- Roman Catholic Diocese v. New York State Department of Health (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1985)
- People ex rel. Vallejo v. New York State Board of Parole (New York Supreme Court 1985)
- People v. Harris Corp. (New York County Courts 1984)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The defendant was apprehended for driving on a state highway at 46 miles an hour in a zone where the State Traffic Commission had announced, by a so-called “ order ”, that the speed should not exceed 35 miles. He was charged with a violation of section 56, subdivision 4, of the former Vehicle and Traffic Law which renders such driving unlawful. His conviction by a justice of the peace was reversed by the county court upon the ground, specifically raised by the defendant, that the commission’s order imposing the speed limitation had not been filed with the Department of State as required by a provision of the State Constitution. The People appeal by leave of the Chief Judge.
In 1939, there was added to the Constitution section 8 of article IV to provide that “ No rule or regulation made by any
We are called upon to decide, first, whether the State Traffic Commission had authority to establish a speed limit by “ order ”, rather than by “ rule ” or“ regulation ”, and, second, whether, in any event, the so-called order amounted to a rule or regulation under the constitutional provision so that failure to file prevented it from being “ effective ”.
The ‘ ‘ order ’ ’ was promulgated in 1954. At that time, the Vehicle and Traffic Law contained no provision for establishing speed limits by means of orders. Under the title, ‘ ‘ Speed and Parking Regulations ”, section 95-c, subdivision 1, of article 7 of the statute authorized the commission to establish, on state highways outside of towns and villages, speed limits higher or lower than the statutory 50-mile maximum. Section 95-h empowered the commission to adopt such ‘ ‘ rules and regulations ” as it deemed necessary to carry out “ the provisions of this article ”. It is the successor statute to section 95-c— section 1620, enacted in 1957—which permits the commission to fix speed limits “ by order, rule or regulation ”. There was, therefore, at the time the order here in question was promulgated, no statute empowering the commission to restrict the speed of automobiles on state highways other than by way of a rule or regulation. In other words, there was no statutory authorization for an “ order ” as such.
In any event, though, it should be treated as a rule or regulation. The term, ‘1 rule or regulation ’ ’, has not, it is true, been the subject of precise definition, but there can be little doubt that, as employed in the constitutional provision, it embraces any kind of legislative or quasi-legislative norm or prescription which establishes a pattern or course of conduct for the future. The label or name employed is not important and, unquestionably, many so-called “ orders ” come within the term. (See, e.g., Revised Record of Constitutional Convention of 1938, Vol. 2,
Thus, in 1938, in discussing the proposed new section 8 of article IV, which was ultimately adopted, members of the Constitutional Convention referred to orders, rules and regulations as synonymous terms (Revised Record, op. cit., pp. 948, 949, 963, 966). Indeed, to show the need for filing such documents in a “ central place,” one member cited difficulties in obtaining orders issued by the Department of Agriculture relating to the price of milk (pp. 941-942). And, in the Wirtz case (1 A D 2d 416, supra),. orders setting minimum wage standards were denominated rules or regulations effective only upon filing with the Department of State as the Constitution required. Furthermore, since the adoption of the constitutional provision in 1939, various state departments and agencies have filed all kinds of quasi-legislative orders, in addition to rules and regulations specifically so labeled, with the Department of State. (See, e.g., N. Y. Off. Comp. of Codes, Rules & Regulations [1945], Vol. 2, p. 965 et seq.; Vol. 3, p. 881 et seq.; Vol. 4, p. 483 et seq.; 1 NYCRR 20.1-28.1; 4 NYCRR 80.1-85.5.)
That the order of the State Traffic Commission here involved falls in the legislative or quasi-legislative category can hardly be doubted. In fixing a speed limit on a state highway, it quite plainly establishes a general course of operation .to be effective for the future and by that token comes within the scope of the “ rule or regulation ” filing requirement of the Constitution.
The district attorney argues, however, that the only purpose of article IV, section 8, is to give notice to the public of the rules and regulations of state bureaus and commissions and that, since the public has notice of speed limits by means of highway signs and markers, the constitutional requirement does not apply to rules or regulations which establish such restrictions.
It is true that the public is apprised of speed limits by means of highway signs and that, in their absence, motorists may not be found guilty of exceeding the speed permitted. (Cf., e.g., People v. Corwin, 304 N. Y. 362, 366.) And, of course, in accordance
As is apparent, therefore, notice was not the only purpose of the constitutional provision. Because of the “ever-increasing body of administrative law,” with constantly new and changing regulations, it was equally important that a “common” and “ definite place ” be provided where the exact content of such rules and regulations, including any changes, might be found. In other words, a ‘ ‘ central ’ ’ place was needed ‘ ‘ where * * * anyone may examine in that one place what the law or rule is that has been enacted affecting his particular interest.” (Revised Record, op. tit., p. 947, per Senator Wagner; see, also, pp. 942, 950, 964, 968,1429; Harris, Administrative Practice and Procedure, 6 Okla. L. Rev. 29, 35.) Otherwise, in a case such as the present, a failure to file, though it would not leave a motorist in ignorance of a posted speed restriction, would prevent him—for instance, following a charge — from examining the contents of the rule establishing such limitation in order to determine its legality, effectiveness or accuracy.
The importance of the requirement of filing is further evidenced by the circumstance that local communities, such as villages and cities, even though they post speed signs, are usually required, before traffic rules may become effective, to file them with the village or city clerk. (Village Law, § 95; General City Law, § 20, subd. 32; see, also, Cherubino v. Meenan, 253 N. Y. 462, 467.) And, so far as state highways are concerned, the Department of State is the comparable central filing
The Constitution, in the clearest of language, requires that every rule and regulation made by board, bureau, officer, authority or commission—“ except such as relates to the organization or internal management ” of such office or agency—be filed in the office of the Department of State if it is to be effective. We know that underlying the provision was the desire to have all rules and regulations affecting the public filed in one, easily available, central place. We should not strive to read exceptions into the section or construe it so as to permit the official in charge of the bureau, commission or authority to avoid the necessity of filing by attaching the label “ order ” or “ statement of policy ” or some other term to what is essentially a rule or regulation. The spirit and design of the constitutional provision are best effectuated by requiring the administrator, if he wishes the rules and regulations of his agency or department to be effective, to file them no matter what label is assigned to them.
The order of the County Court dismissing the information should be affirmed.
Chief Judge Desmond and Judges Dye, Froessel, Van Voorhis, Burke and Foster concur.
Order affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.