Gulf Oil Corp. v. Buram Realty Co.
Cases that cite this one
20 later published cases cite this decision.
- Peter-Michael, Inc. v. Sea Shell Associates (Conn. 1998)
- In re Touloumis (United States Bankruptcy Court, S.D. New York 1994)
- White Castle System, Inc. v. Blohm (2d Cir. 1986)
- White Castle System, Inc. v. Blohm (2d Cir. 1986)
- Tubbs v. Hendrickson (New York Supreme Court 1976)
- Peter-Michael v. Sea Shell Associates, No. Cv 96-0392382 S (Jan. 14, 1997) (Connecticut Superior Court 1997)
- McMillan v. Marengo (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2021)
- Koppelman v. Barrett (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 2015)
- Mulonet v. Exxonmobil Oil Corp. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2011)
- Galapo v. Feinberg (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1999)
- Dime Savings Bank of New York, FSB v. Montague Street Realty Associates (N.Y. 1997)
- Trump Management Inc. v. Tuberman (Civil Court of the City of New York 1995)
- Ludlam Stead, Ltd. v. Rezza (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1989)
- Fresh Pond Road Associates v. Estate of Schacht (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1986)
- Jefpaul Garage Corp. v. Presbyterian Hospital (N.Y. 1984)
- Power Test Petroleum Distributors v. Baker-Tripi Realty Corp. (New York Supreme Court 1984)
- V.A.T. Collision Corp. v. 1783 84th Street Realty Corp. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1982)
- Loral Realty Co. v. Beauty Development Corp. (Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York 1982)
- Abramovich v. Board of Education (New York Supreme Court 1977)
- Transit Drive-In Theater, Inc. v. Outdoor Theatre Caterers, Inc. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1976)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The question to be answered is whether a purchase option clause in a lease which could be exercised ‘ ‘ at any time during the term of this lease ” became part of 22 successive extension agreements which were entered into after the expiration of the original term of the lease as amended.
The courts below have properly held that it did not.
The last extension agreement, just as each of the 20 previous extension agreements, referred specifically “ to that certain lease agreement covering the above premises ” and purported to further extend ‘ ‘ the term of this lease ’ ’. Each specified that acceptance would extend the lease ‘ ‘ under the terms set forth herein ”. In all but 3 of these 20 extension agreements the term was extended for 6 months, and in the other 3 for 12 months.
Both parties have moved for summary judgment. Appellant’s motion is based upon the lease and the subsequent extension agreements, while respondent, in support of its cross motion, offered proof by affidavit.
In determining whether the purchase option was in effect when it was sought to be exercised 19 years after the making of the original lease, it is necessary to construe the agreements. That interpretation will be the decisive factor in the disposition of the question presented to us.
Since here the option to purchase “ during the term of this lease ” was not exercised during the term of the original lease as amended or during the term as extended by the exercise of an option to renew contained in the lease, the period for which the original lease has been extended is not considered as if it was a part of an entire term.
Applying this test to these agreements, we are of the opinion that the respondent was entitled to summary judgment as the language which appellant relies on in the extension agreements is, at best, of double meaning. The rule is well stated in an English case Sherwood v. Tucker ([1924] 2 Ch. 440, 445) where the question was the same as here. The court wrote: “It is quite clear that a landlord may be prepared to give to his tenant an option to purchase at a fixed price for a limited period of time. The circumstance of value may enable both parties to fix upon a sum which will stand good for a definite time. It is quite another thing to say that the same considerations apply where there is an extension and a renewed extension of the term. * * * the landlord may be content for a fixed time to be
Here, although each of the agreements refers specifically to the lease by date and location of the premises, there is nothing definitely stated in the agreements that manifests a clear intention to incorporate the purchase option as one of the terms of the extension.
There are compelling circumstances which favor the position taken by respondent and which tend to negate any asserted intent to continue the purchase option clause in force during the agreed extension of the term. While the lease limited the exercise of the purchase option to the term of the lease, there are six other provisions in the lease which are stated in effect not only during the term of the lease, but also any “ extension thereof ”. A fact of considerable importance is that these business people knew what the option to purchase ‘ ‘ at any time during the term of this lease ” meant. It obviously did not mean to include the period covered by 20-odd extensions of the term of the lease by independent agreements which commenced to take effect after the expiration of the original lease. When the parties negotiated the agreements for the extension of the term of each of the 22 occasions, neither party was bound by the provisions of the lease. Under such conditions it would not be reasonable to assume that a provision of a lease which is not an essential element of the landlord and tenant relationship is to be read into the extension agreements.
Since, therefore, the agreements in the case at bar contain no unmistakable language from which it may be found that the parties intended the purchase option to continue during the periods of the extensions, the dismissal of the complaint was proper.
Accordingly, the judgment of the Appellate Division should be affirmed, with costs.
Chief Judge Desmond and Judges Dye, Fuld, Fboessel, Van Voorhis and Foster concur.
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.