Gallagher v. Regan
Cases that cite this one
34 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Torre v. County of Nassau (N.Y. 1995)
- Nite Moves Entertainment, Inc. v. City of Boise (United States District Court for the District of Idaho 2001)
- Corn v. City of Oakland City (Ind. Ct. App. 1981)
- COUNTY OF ERIE v. M/A-COM, INC. (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2013)
- Heron v. City of Binghamton (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2003)
- Lawrence v. County of Greene (New York Supreme Court 1998)
- New York Public Interest Research Group v. Dinkins (N.Y. 1994)
- Nickels v. New York City Housing Authority (New York Supreme Court 1994)
- Swanick v. Erie County Legislature (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1984)
- Poillucci v. Pattison (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1983)
- Henry v. Noto (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1980)
- Matter of Grant v. Town of Lewisboro (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2015)
- Matter of Glass v. County of Suffolk (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2015)
- Baldwin Union Free School District v. County of Nassau (N.Y. 2014)
- Town of North Hempstead v. County of Nassau (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2013)
- Town of North Hempstead v. County of Nassau (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2013)
- Brunswick Smart Growth, Inc. v. Town Board (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2008)
- Lamb v. Town of Esopus (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2006)
- Mohr v. Greenan (New York Supreme Court 2005)
- DeSantis v. City of Jamestown (New York Supreme Court 2002)
- Paradis v. Town of Schroeppel (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 2001)
- Council of New York v. Giuliani (N.Y. 1999)
- Hart v. County of Chautauqua (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1997)
- Campana v. Chiseri (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1997)
- Council of New York v. Giuliani (New York Supreme Court 1997)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
We hold that positions in Erie County government established by the County Charter and the Administrative Code cannot be abolished by the County Legislature by striking salary appropriations for such positions from the budget submitted by the County Executive.
As members of the Erie County Legislature and as citizen-taxpayers, petitioners initiated this litigation by submission to the Appellate Division of a controversy on an agreed statement of facts under CPLR 3222, presenting several questions relating to various items involved in the 1977 Erie County budget. Those questions were resolved by the judgment entered in the court below, only one ordering paragraph of which is before us for review on this appeal taken by petitioners by leave of this court. That paragraph provides that the 1977 budget "shall not include the positions of Deputy County Executive, Deputy Commissioner of Public Works-Buildings and Grounds, Deputy Director of Purchasing, Deputy Commissioner-Recreation, County Forester and Commissioner of Environmental Quality.”
The submission of controversy agreed to by the parties, as amended by their conduct and oral stipulation on argument,
Each of the five positions in question was expressly created by one or more provisions either of the County Charter or of the Administrative Code enacted to set forth the details of county government in harmony with the charter (Deputy County Executive—Erie County Charter, §§ 304, 309; Deputy Commissioner of Public Works-Division of Buildings and Grounds—Erie County Administrative Code, §§ 10.01, 10.04; Deputy Director of Purchasing—Erie County Administrative Code, § 3.06, subd a; Deputy Commissioner-Recreation—Erie County Administrative Code, § 7.01, subd [b]; County Forester —Erie County Administrative Code, § 7.04). Both the charter and the Administrative Code may be amended by a local law only (Erie County Charter, § 2002; Municipal Home Rule Law, § 2, subd 9; § 33, subd 1; § 32, subd 2; Erie County Charter, § 202, subd c; Erie County Administrative Code, § 20.01). A local law is subject to an initial veto by the County Executive and may not receive approval by him until a public hearing thereon has been held before him (Erie County Charter, § 205; Municipal Home Rule Law, § 21). The adoption of the county budget, however, is effected by action of a majority of the County Legislature, as to which the County Executive may exercise a veto with respect to increases made over the tentative budget by the County Legislature but not with respect to legislative decreases (Erie County Charter, § 1803).
In the present case, the County Legislature’s omission of salary items for the five positions (representing a decrease in the budget), unlike a local law enacted by the same body, could not be vetoed by the County Executive. The check and balance assured by the right of veto in the elected executive
Respondents’ reliance on section 204 of the County Law is misplaced. That section provides, insofar as pertinent: "In addition to those positions of employment specifically provided by law, the board of supervisors shall have power to establish positions of employment and may abolish the same. The establishment and abolition of such positions may be by local law, by resolution or by the adoption of the budget.” It is respondents’ contention that the reference to positions "provided by law” relates only to positions created by general State law, and that inasmuch as the positions here involved were created by charter and Administrative Code rather than general law, the County Legislature could exercise the authority to abolish these positions granted it under section 204. To this argument, several answers can be made. First, it is not clear that "provided by law” does not embrace provisions of
Similarly, we reject the contention that the positions in question—expressly created as they are by the County Charter or Administrative Code—fall within the ambit of particular code provisions which condition the authority to create offices on appropriations being made therefor by the Legislature. A distinction must be made between the nonspecific "deputies, other officers and employees”, which heads of administrative units may appoint under subdivision d of section 3.09 of the Erie County Administrative Code within appropriations, and those offices particularly defined and described by the charter or other provisions of the code.
In the terms of the controversy submitted by the parties, petitioners are not entitled to the judgment rendered by the court below directing that the five subject positions not be included in the 1977 Erie County budget. The judgment, insofar as appealed from, should therefore be reversed, without costs, and the case remitted to the Appellate Division for judgment in accordance with this opinion.
Judgment, insofar as appealed from, reversed , etc.
. As agreed by the parties, all questions as to the last-named position—Commissioner of Environmental Quality—have become moot and it will therefore not be considered further.
. While the submission in form requested only a determination as to the first three of the five described positions, it appears that the parties have proceeded throughout on the assumption that all five positions are properly in issue and have addressed them all in their arguments and briefs before us.
. As to both local laws and budget increases an executive veto could be overriden by a vote of two thirds of the members of the Legislature (Erie County Charter, §§ 205, 1803, subd c).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.