Ohio Court of Appeals, 1923

Smolinski v. Jaworski

Smolinski v. Jaworski
Ohio Court of Appeals · Decided April 16, 1923 · Sullivan
1 Ohio Law. Abs. 393; 1923 Ohio Misc. LEXIS 1837

Smolinski v. Jaworski

Opinion of the Court

SULLIVAN, J.

Epitomized Opinion

These were actions for real estate commissions. The petitions set up causes of action founded upon contracts for the procuring of a purchaser for the sale of real estate which was afterwards sold. During the course of the trial it developed that the contracts between the broker and the representative owners of the real estate called for a stipulated commission for the trade or exchange of properties instead of independent contracts for the procuring Of a purchaser. The cases were tried before Judge Jowell of the Common Fleas Court of Cuyahoga ounty, and resulted in judgments for the plaintiffs. ■Fhe defendants prosecuted error. In reversing the judgments of Judge Powell, the Court of Appeals 1 leld:

1.As there was a fundamental variation between t he petition and the proof the court erred in per-i hitting such evidence to go to the jury.

I 2. Inasmuch as a power to sell does not carry with it a power to lease or exchange real estate, «he court erred in its charge when it submitted ssues to the jury not raised by the pleadings.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.