City of Tiffin v. Hufford, Unpublished Decision (11-20-1998)
City of Tiffin v. Hufford, Unpublished Decision (11-20-1998)
Opinion of the Court
OPINION
This is an appeal by the City of Tiffin from the judgment of the Municipal Court of Tiffin, Ohio, dismissing the charges against defendant Anthony L. Hufford and finding Tiffin Codified Ordinance sectionThe City of Tiffin alleges1 that on May 1, 1998, Tiffin Police Officer Fredrick W. Stevens was in his patrol cruiser travelling southbound on South Washington street when he became aware that the driver of a car in front of him was playing loud music. Officer Stevens radioed other units to determine if another officer was further south on South Washington street, so that second officer could measure the distance at which the car's music remained audible. Officer Aaron M. Russell answered the call and parked his patrol cruiser on South Washington street. He then measured off a distance of 162 feet from his cruiser, and stood at that point waiting for the car to approach. As the car reached Officer Russell's cruiser, he determined that the music was plainly audible from his position and radioed that information to Officer Stevens. Officer Stevens proceeded to initiate a traffic stop of the car, which was being driven by defendant Anthony L. Hufford. Officer Stevens issued defendant a citation for violating Tiffin Codified Ordinance section
THE TRIAL COURT ERRED IN DISMISSING THE CASE AGAINST DEFENDANT. [SIC] WHILE FINDING ENFORCEMENT OF TIFFIN CITY ORDINANCE SECTION
509.11 (a) AN UNCONSTITUTIONAL INFRINGEMENT OF DEFENDANT'SFIRST AMENDMENT RIGHT TO FREE EXPRESSION.
On the authority of this Court's decision in City of Tiffinv. McEwen, Seneca App. No. 13-98-28, unreported, the City of Tiffin's sole assignment of error is sustained. The judgment of the Tiffin Municipal Court is reversed and the case is remanded for proceedings consistent with this opinion.
Judgment reversed and cause remanded. BRYANT and HADLEY, JJ., concur.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.