Quillen v. Deaton, Unpublished Decision (2-2-1998)
Quillen v. Deaton, Unpublished Decision (2-2-1998)
Concurring Opinion
Reluctantly, I must concur in the decision on the first assignment of error; however, in the interest of fairness on the second assignment, I would remand for findings of fact and conclusions of law.
Opinion of the Court
OPINION
This is an accelerated appeal arising from a decision by the Butler County Court of Common Pleas, Domestic Relations Division, finding that the parties' child, Angie Deaton, became emancipated on her twenty-first birthday.Defendant-appellant, Thomas Deaton, and plaintiff-appellee, Connie Deaton Quillen, were divorced pursuant to a divorce decree filed by the Butler County Court of Common Pleas, Domestic Relations Division, on June 7, 1973. At the time of the divorce, the parties had two minor children, Monica, born on November 30, 1968, and Angie, born on October 26, 1969. The divorce decree incorporated the parties' oral separation agreement and provided, in pertinent part, that "[appellant] shall pay to the [appellee] as and for child support for the parties' two minor children the sum of $30.00 per week through the Bureau of Support * * *."1
Angie resided with appellee until she turned twenty-one years old while Monica moved out of appellee's residence following her eighteenth birthday and graduation from high school. Appellant did not pay any child support to appellee following the childrens' respective eighteenth birthdays. On April 22, 1997, appellee filed a motion for contempt based upon appellant's failure to pay child support following each child's eighteenth birthday. Appellee argued that appellant's obligation to pay child support continued until the children turned twenty-one years old. Appellant filed a motion requesting the trial court to find that the children became emancipated upon reaching the age of eighteen.
On July 14, 1997, the trial court filed an entry finding that Angie became emancipated on her twenty-first birthday and Monica became emancipated after graduating from high school and moving out of appellee's home. Appellant now appeals from the July 14, 1997 entry, only as it pertains to Angie, setting forth the following assignment of error:
The trial court erred in finding that Angie Quillen was emancipated on her twenty-first birthday.
In his assignment of error, appellant contends that the trial court erred by finding that Angie was not emancipated until her twenty-first birthday. Appellant argues that his child support obligation should have terminated when Angie turned eighteen years old because the duration of his support obligation was not specified in the parties' 1973 divorce decree. Appellant further argues that even if he was obligated to pay child support until Angie turned twenty-one, his obligation to pay ceased when Angie turned eighteen because she was emancipated at that time.
Effective January 1, 1974, the Ohio legislature changed the age of majority from twenty-one to eighteen years of age. R.C.
Where a pre-1974 child support order contains either an explicit or implicit duration, the support obligation continues until the child or children reach the age of twenty-one, the age of majority prior to 1974. See Nokes,
Since the divorce decree involved in the instant case refers only to the duration of child support in terms of "minor children," which was precisely the language used in the order considered by the supreme court in Nokes, the Nokes decision controls the disposition of this case. See Nokes,
Further, we decline to disturb the trial court's finding that Angie became emancipated at age twenty-one. The evidence contained in the record before us is insufficient to consider appellant's argument that Angie became emancipated prior to age twenty-one.3 We cannot determine whether the findings and orders of the trial court are an abuse of discretion without reviewing the proceedings that led to the trial court's decision. Therefore, we will presume the validity and regularity of the proceedings below with respect to the trial court's determination that Angie became emancipated at the age of twenty-one. Knapp v. Edwards Laboratories (1980),
POWELL, J., concurs.
KOEHLER, J., concurs separately.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.